paper in a folder of his own, not looking at it, the way a man does not look at
a thing he has already decided about.
Carol Hensley called the meeting to order at seven o'clock precisely, with the
gavel she had used for eleven years, and she chaired the opening the way she
had chaired a hundred meetings before it: agenda adopted, minutes approved,
correspondence noted, each item taken up and put down with the clean
finality of a broker closing a file. She wore the navy suit. Her hair was done.
If she knew what the night contained she had dressed for it the way she
would have dressed for a closing, and Tom, who had come to understand her
better than he had ever wanted to, recognized the composure for what it was:
not ignorance, and not exactly courage, but a professional's conviction that a
meeting, like a market, will behave if it is properly run. She intended this to
be the hundred-and-first meeting she had chaired in that room, and she
intended it to end the way the other hundred had ended, with the association
intact and the minutes approved and everyone driving home under the
gatehouse light.
The president's report came first, as it always did, and it was the best speech
she ever gave in that room, which Tom understood even as he listened to it
93
with his folder on his knees and his affidavit four months recorded. One
Heron Bay, she said. That was the phrase, and she built the report on it the
way the renderings were built on the easel: the marina as the completion of a
promise the developer had made and the association had inherited; the
regularization of the Point Road lots as the unfinished paperwork of that
same promise, an intent thirty years old that the present board had merely,
finally, carried to the register's office; the lawsuit — she did not call it Tom's
lawsuit; she called it the Point Road litigation, as one speaks of weather in
another county — as a cost the community was bearing together, as it bore
all its costs, out of the same dues that had paved the roads and staffed the
gatehouse and dredged the lake. She spoke of continuity. She spoke of the
lake as a single body of water that did not recognize the phase line, and of
the roads as a single system, and of fairness, which was the word she had
built her presidency on and the word she plainly still believed was hers.
Listening to her, a stranger would have thought the annexation was a road
already paved, graded and striped and driven on for years, and that a few
men with old maps had arrived one spring to dig it up for sport. She did not
lie, Tom noted, in any particular he could name. She arranged. It was the gift
and it was the whole of the trouble, and he had heard it so many times now
that he could hear the joins in it, the places where one true thing had been
laid over a missing one so smoothly that the surface read as solid.
She finished to the applause of perhaps a third of the room, which in Heron
Bay in November was a kind of honesty in itself, and she set the report down
and opened the agenda to the item the meeting had been called for, in the flat
voice of a woman moving to old business. Phase Three, she said. The Point
Road matter. The floor was open.
Tom had spent the drive over composing the face he intended to wear, and he
94
wore it now: the face of a man attending a meeting about a marina. Beside
him, Ed had brought nothing but a thermos and the particular patience of a
retired machinist who has been promised, by his friend of thirty years, that he
would not have to speak. Molly Tran sat on Tom's other side with a legal pad
she did not write on. She had told him in the parking lot that her function
tonight was ornamental and evidentiary in equal parts — she was there so
that the association could see, without anyone having to say it, that the Point
Road had brought its lawyer to a membership meeting and had dressed her in
a gray suit. Her pad stayed blank. Everything she needed the night to
produce, she had explained, was going to be produced by the association
itself, out of its own files, in its own voices; her whole practice that evening
was to be present for it, like a notary. Tom thought of the chancellor in
October, saying much the same thing from the bench with considerably less
economy.
It was not Tom who began it. That had been the plan — no speech, no
presentation, the record carried in by other hands — and the record, when it
came, came in exactly the order his folder had predicted, which gave him the
strange sensation all evening of watching a survey he had already run being
retraced by a crew that did not know he had run it. A member in the third
row, a gray, careful man named Prescott who kept a sailboat and a set of the
association's minutes going back to 1994, stood and asked the question in the
form the room had needed someone to ask it in since April. He would like,
he said, to have the recorded supplemental declaration identified. The one
that annexed the Point Road lots. By book and by page, if the secretary had