THE GIRL AGAINST THE PATROL CAR: THE CORNER, THE CAMERA, AND THE MOTHER HE NEVER ASKED ABOUT

Chapter 19

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Dana came to the Brooks house the next morning carrying her phone in a small cloth bag, as if it were something breakable. She had called first, and Simone had said to come to the side door and not to speak to anyone on the street about why she was there. Dana was an older woman, steady on her feet, and she did not waste time on small talk. She sat at the kitchen table, set the phone down, and said she had a second video, longer than the one her son had filmed, and she wanted Simone and the investigators to see it in full. Simone thanked her and asked her to play it from the start, and Dana pressed the screen with a finger that did not tremble.

The video began at three forty eight in the afternoon, according to the time stamp in the corner. It showed the corner in bright sun. The cruiser was already past the stop line, and the body of the car blocked the crosswalk from end to end. The walk signal glowed, and Dana's voice could be heard in the background, calm and firm, saying the signal was on and the girl had the right to cross. Dana had held the camera steady with both hands, and the frame stayed wide enough to show the cruiser, the signal, and the girl all at once.

Aaliyah entered the frame from the side, walking with her sack and her book and her bottle of water. She moved at an ordinary pace, neither hurrying nor dawdling, and she kept to the crosswalk. Her hands were empty except for what she carried, and her head was up. The cruiser did not move. Then the officer stepped out, and Dana's camera caught the first order and the way Aaliyah stopped at once. It caught her hands going up before he reached her, empty and open, and it caught the way she held them there while he closed the distance. Simone watched without speaking, and Dana watched Simone, and neither woman looked away from the screen.

The video went on, and it showed what the shorter video had only hinted at. It showed the officer taking the wrist and pulling the girl toward the cruiser. It showed her face turning toward the hot metal and her shoulder pressing against it. It showed Dana speaking from the crosswalk, telling the officer the girl had done nothing wrong and that her hands had been up. It showed the sack and the book and the bottle falling, and the girl being told to pick them up herself. The sound was clear, and the picture was clear enough that no one watching could mistake the order of events.

Simone asked Dana to play one part again, the part near the start, and Dana moved the video back. They watched the walk signal again, and the cruiser past the line, and Aaliyah's hands rising before the first order. Simone asked Dana to note the time when the hands went up, and Dana pointed to the stamp and said the time aloud. Simone wrote it in the notebook, along with the length of the video, three minutes and forty eight seconds, and the fact that Dana had filmed it herself from the crosswalk. She asked Dana whether anyone else had held the phone, and Dana said no one had. She asked whether the video had been cut or shortened, and Dana said it had not, and that the file on the phone was the whole recording from start to finish.

Dana said she had brought the video to the television station the evening before, and to the investigators as well, because she did not want it to sit on one phone only. She said the station had played the full recording that night, and people had begun to write to the mayor in large numbers. She did not sound proud. She sounded tired. Simone said Dana had done the right thing by making more than one copy and giving the original to the proper people. She said Dana would be asked to tell the same story again, in the same plain words, when the time came. Dana said she would, and that she had told it the same way each time.

Aaliyah came into the kitchen while the video was still on the screen, and Simone paused it at once. She did not want her daughter to watch herself being pressed against the cruiser again so soon after the clinic visit. Aaliyah asked what they were watching, and Simone said it was Dana's video, and that it showed the truth of the afternoon. Aaliyah asked whether the video showed her hands, and Dana answered, saying yes, it showed her hands up before the officer touched her. Aaliyah nodded and went back to the couch.

After Dana left, Simone copied the notebook entry onto a clean page and added the new facts to the folder. The second video fixed three things the first video had left open. It fixed the position of the cruiser, past the stop line and across the crosswalk. It fixed the signal, on and with time left. It fixed the hands, up before the first order and before any touch. With those three facts settled, the story the officer might tell later would have to answer the picture. Simone closed the folder and set it back on the shelf. The second video did not change what had happened. It made what had happened harder to deny.

Chapter Twenty

News in the same category

THE GIRL AGAINST THE PATROL CAR: THE CORNER, THE CAMERA, AND THE MOTHER HE NEVER ASKED ABOUT

45 Part