THE GIRL AGAINST THE PATROL CAR: THE CORNER, THE CAMERA, AND THE MOTHER HE NEVER ASKED ABOUT

Chapter 30

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Two weeks after the stop, the federal grand jury in Baltimore returned its decision. The indictment held three counts against Trent Mallerie, and each count named a different part of what he had done on that July afternoon and in the days that followed. The first count charged him with taking away the rights of a child while acting under color of law, under 18 U.S.C. section 242, by using force that was far beyond anything the moment required, and by causing the injuries that Elena Ruiz had written down at the urgent care clinic. The second count charged him with falsifying records, for the written report that said Aaliyah had lunged and swung at him, when the videos and the camera log showed that she had done neither. The third count charged him with obstruction, for switching off the body camera, for the file that had been opened and changed, and for the pages that had gone missing before the file reached the FBI.

Simone heard the news from Rebecca Halpern, who called her herself, in the late afternoon, and who spoke carefully, as a supervisor speaks when the news is both welcome and hard. Simone thanked her, and she wrote down the three counts in her notebook, in the same neat hand she used for everything, and she read them twice, to be sure she had them right. She was screened off the case and would not prosecute it, and she accepted that, because the case belonged to her daughter, and not to her work. When she put the telephone down, she went to find Aaliyah, who was sitting at the kitchen table with her schoolbooks, and she told her, simply, that the grand jury had spoken, and that there would be a trial, and that the trial would take time, and that none of it was her fault, and that none of it would be asked of her alone.

Mallerie surrendered at the federal courthouse in Baltimore, on a morning that was bright and cold for the season. He arrived with Gavin Sloan beside him, walked past the cameras outside, and gave himself up to the officers waiting inside. The hearing that followed was short, and it was formal, and it set the conditions under which he would wait for trial. He was released under strict terms. He had to give up his passport. He was not to touch or own any weapon. He was not to contact Aaliyah, or Dana, or Malik, in any way, by telephone, by message, or through any other person. He was not to leave the state of Maryland without the permission of the court. He listened to each condition as it was read, and he nodded, and he signed the papers that were put in front of him, and he left the courthouse with Sloan, into a car that took him away from the cameras and the questions.

In Westbridge, the news traveled from one kitchen to another. Malik heard it from his mother, went to his room, and watched his seventy three second video once more, feeling for the first time that the filming had mattered. Dana heard it at the crosswalk, nodded, said very little, and walked home slowly, thinking of the long road ahead.

At school, Aaliyah heard it from Jordan, who had heard it from a teacher, and who told her quietly, in the hallway, between classes, so that no one else would have to hear it first. Aaliyah thanked her friend, went on to her next class, and said nothing about the indictment to anyone else that day. That evening, she asked her mother whether the trial would mean she had to speak in front of strangers, and Simone told her the truth, that she would, and that the courtroom would be quiet, and that telling the truth slowly was enough, and that no question, however sharp, could change what the videos showed, and that Daniel Cho would prepare her, and that she would not be alone, and that her mother would be there, in the gallery, as a mother, and not as a prosecutor. Aaliyah was quiet for a while, and then she said that she could do it, and Simone believed her, because her daughter had already done the hardest part, which was to tell the truth on the day it happened, and to keep telling it ever since.

The trial date was set for the winter, seven months away, and the waiting began the next morning. The indictment did not end the story. It marked the place where the story changed, from a question of what had happened at a corner, to a question of what the law would do about it. The videos were preserved. The camera log was preserved. The audit log was preserved. The missing pages were listed by name. The fourteen complaints were part of the record, and the pattern they showed was part of the record, and the town that had watched a girl be pressed against a hot cruiser would now watch a courtroom do its work, slowly, carefully, and in the open. Simone put her notebook away, and she made supper, and she and Aaliyah ate together, and outside their window the evening came on, ordinary and quiet, and the house was at peace, for that night at least, with the knowledge that the truth had been written down, and that it would not be unwritten.

Chapter Thirty One

The Mother in the Gallery, Not at the Table

News in the same category

THE GIRL AGAINST THE PATROL CAR: THE CORNER, THE CAMERA, AND THE MOTHER HE NEVER ASKED ABOUT

45 Part