Trent Mallerie took the stand in his suit, with his hands resting on the rail in front of him, and he spoke in the steady voice of a man who had told his version many times. He said Aaliyah Brooks had refused his orders, had fought him, and had swung at him, and that she had been standing in the roadway where she had no right to stand. He said she had been about to run, and that he had used only the smallest force needed to keep her still and keep the scene safe. He said he had not slammed her, and that he had guided her to the cruiser, and that the contact had been brief and controlled. He said the body camera had gone off on its own, or that he did not remember touching it, and that he had written his report from memory in the evening, when the day was still fresh. He said the words in the report were his own honest account, and that the films showed only pieces of a longer encounter, pieces that made a lawful stop look worse than it was.
Sloan led him gently through the stop, step by step, and Mallerie answered each question with the same phrases the jury had already heard in the reports. He said she had refused to identify herself, and that she had given false information about her birth date. He said she had been combative, and that he had feared she would flee into traffic. He said he had called for a supervisor, and that the sergeant had agreed she could go, which showed, in his telling, that the matter had been minor all along. He said he had acted in good faith, and that he had believed every order he gave was lawful. He said the settlement in the earlier case, the one involving Darius Bell, had nothing to do with this stop, and that the complaints in his file had all been closed without discipline, which showed, in his telling, that they had no weight. He said the data about stops showed where he had been assigned, not what he had intended, and that the phrases in his reports were simply the language officers used. When Sloan sat down, Mallerie folded his hands and waited, as if the hard part were over.
Daniel Cho stood, and the room changed its temperature. He did not raise his voice. He played the films. First he played the 73 seconds filmed by Malik, and he asked Mallerie to watch the girl raise her hands before the first order was finished. Mallerie said he did not recall the order of events exactly. Cho played the second film, the one Dana had made, 3 minutes 48 seconds, and he asked Mallerie to watch the cruiser sitting past the stop line, across the crosswalk, while the walk signal was on. Mallerie said the position of the cruiser had not been his focus. Cho read the camera log aloud, the start at 3:16:58, the 41 seconds, the switch off by hand at 3:17:39, before any touch, and he asked Mallerie how a camera switches itself off. Mallerie said he did not remember touching it. Cho read the radio call at 3:19, the words about a combative juvenile, and he asked how a call made after the push could describe a threat that came before it. Mallerie said the call had summarized the whole encounter. Cho read the messages sent at 3:32, the words about a girl pulling a card about her mother, and he asked Mallerie whether he had written them. Mallerie said he did not recall writing them, and then he said the words were a private joke, and then he stopped, because the jury was watching him change his answer in front of them.
Cho asked about the report filed at 8 in the evening, the one that said Aaliyah had lunged and swung. He asked Mallerie to point to the moment in any film where she lunged, and Mallerie could not. He asked him to point to the moment where she swung, and Mallerie said the films did not show everything. Cho asked about the missing pages, the force analysis, the scene map, the discipline history, and Mallerie said he did not handle the file after he submitted it. Cho asked about the 14 complaints and the six that described the same pattern, and Mallerie said he did not remember the details. Cho asked about the search of his own phone, the search for the name of Simone Brooks late that evening, and Mallerie said he had wanted to understand the case. Cho asked, quietly, whether Mallerie had known, when he pressed a twelve year old child against hot metal, that her mother was a federal prosecutor. Mallerie said he had not known, and that it would not have changed his conduct, and the answer hung in the air, because it admitted what the films had already shown, that the conduct had never depended on who she was. Cho thanked him and sat down, and the defense expert followed, saying the force had been reasonable, until Cho asked him to name one threat the girl had posed, one run, one blow, and the expert, after a long pause, said he could name none. The defense rested, and the room waited for the jury to be told what to do.
Chapter Thirty Nine
The Nine Hours