THE GIRL AGAINST THE PATROL CAR: THE CORNER, THE CAMERA, AND THE MOTHER HE NEVER ASKED ABOUT

Chapter 37

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Lucas Dwire walked into the courtroom in a suit that did not fit him the way a uniform once had, and he kept his eyes down as he crossed to the stand. He had already pleaded guilty in a separate state case about the records, and he had already lost his rank and his certification, and the jury knew it before he spoke, because Cho said it plainly in his first question. Dwire answered in a low voice, and he did not look at Mallerie while he answered. He said he had been Mallerie's direct supervisor, and also the man who spoke for him when the union was involved, and that the two roles had sat badly together from the start. He said he had approved Mallerie's reports for years without reading them the way a supervisor should, signing where a signature was needed and moving on to the next file. He said the reports used the same phrases so often that he had stopped noticing them, and that when a complaint came in he had treated it as a problem to be closed rather than a story to be checked. He said he had marked complaints unfounded or cleared the officer, and that no discipline had followed, and that the pattern had gone on because no one above him had asked him to stop.

Cho asked him about the afternoon of the stop. Dwire said he had arrived after the girl was already against the cruiser, and that he had seen the red marks on her wrist and the redness on her face, and that he had asked Mallerie whether medical help was needed. He said Mallerie had said no, and that he had accepted the answer and let the girl walk home, without taking the name of a single witness and without calling for help. He said he had told her to walk in a straight line and to cross at the light, as if she had been the one who needed instruction, and that he had been ashamed of those words ever since. He said he had not written down what the girl said, and had not written down what Dana said, and that the record of that hour was thin because he had made it thin. He said he had gone back to the station and sat with Mallerie while the first version of events was put together, and that he had not pressed for the truth when the truth would have been hard to hear.

Cho asked about the file. Dwire said he had opened the file at 4:40 in the afternoon on the day of the stop, before it was sealed, and that he had downloaded it and kept a copy. He said he had told Mallerie not to put certain things on the record, and that he had warned him, by phone, not to submit a report that would not hold up. He said Mallerie had submitted it anyway, at 8 in the evening, with claims that the girl had lunged and swung at him, claims Dwire said he had not seen and did not believe. He said the file that later went to the investigators ran 24 pages, and that it was missing the force analysis, the scene map and the discipline history, and that he knew the file had once been longer, because he had seen the longer version himself. He said the audit log, 27 pages, had shown the openings and the downloads and the changes, and that Rosa Mendes had found it and reported it, and that he had not argued with her findings because they were true. He said he had tried to protect a man he supervised, and that in doing so he had failed the girl at the corner, the department, and himself, and that the state case had given him a sentence and taken his certification, and that the loss was fair.

Sloan rose for the cross examination, and his manner was careful, because a witness who has already admitted fault is hard to shake. He asked Dwire whether he was testifying to win favor, and Dwire said he had already been sentenced in the state case, and that no favor was left to win. Sloan asked whether Dwire might be shifting blame to save his own name, and Dwire said his name was already lost, and that he was speaking because the jury deserved a full record. Sloan asked whether Dwire had truly seen the marks, and Dwire said he had, and that he could still picture them. Sloan asked whether Dwire had told Mallerie to lie, and Dwire said he had not used that word, and that he had told him to be careful about the record, and that careful had meant silent, and that silent had meant wrong. Sloan sat down, and Cho asked one last question, whether Dwire would have approved the report if he had watched the films first. Dwire said no, and that he would have called for medical help and taken witness names, and that he would have done the job he had been given instead of the job he had chosen. He stepped down without looking at the defense table, and Simone, watching from the gallery, closed her eyes for a moment, because the truth had finally been spoken by the man who had helped to hide it, and it had come late, but it had come.

Chapter Thirty Eight

The Officer Who Took the Stand

News in the same category

THE GIRL AGAINST THE PATROL CAR: THE CORNER, THE CAMERA, AND THE MOTHER HE NEVER ASKED ABOUT

45 Part