The Night the Report Was Filed
Trent Mallerie sat at his kitchen table after dark with a lined pad in front of him and a pen that kept stopping in his hand. The house was quiet. His badge, his gun and his cruiser had been taken that evening. On the television in the next room, the news was running the same short clip again, and he had turned the sound down so low that only the picture moved. He did not need the sound. He knew what the picture showed. He also knew what a written report could do that a picture could not. A picture showed a moment. A report gave the moment a reason, and a reason could change what the moment meant.
He had been told, in training and in years of habit, that a report should be filed the same day, while the details were fresh. He told himself that was what he was doing. He wrote his name at the top, and his badge number, and the time and the corner. Then he stopped, because the next part was the part that mattered, and he had to decide what to put down. He thought about the walk signal and the cruiser past the line, and the hands going up, and the videos. He thought about the words caught on the body camera before it went dark. Each thought pressed on the next, and none made the writing easier.
He wrote that the girl had been standing in the roadway. He wrote that she had refused to identify herself and refused commands. He wrote that she had tried to flee. He wrote that she had lunged at him and swung at him, and that he had used only the pressure needed to control her and guide her to the car. He wrote that there had been no strikes. He wrote the words in a steady hand, and as he wrote them the afternoon began to sound different in his own mind. The girl in the report was older and harder, a problem to be handled, and the officer in the report was patient and careful. He read the page back and felt, for a moment, steadier than he had felt all evening.
The phone rang at eight fourteen. It was Lucas Dwire, and his voice was low and urgent. Dwire asked what Mallerie was doing, and Mallerie said he was writing his report. Dwire told him to stop. He told him not to submit anything that night, and to get a lawyer before he put another word on paper. He said the videos were already out, and anything written now would be read beside the pictures. He said a lawyer would know what to file and when, and a rushed report would only give the investigators something to hold against him. Mallerie listened without speaking, the pen still in his hand.
Mallerie said the report was nearly done, and waiting would look worse. Dwire said waiting would look careful, and filing would look desperate, and he repeated the instruction slowly, so there could be no mistake. He said to put the pen down, close the pad, and call a lawyer in the morning. He said he was speaking as a supervisor and as a union representative, and he was trying to protect him. Mallerie thanked him, in a voice that sounded calm, and said he understood. When the call ended he sat with the phone on the table and the pad open in front of him.
He picked up the pen again. He told himself Dwire was being cautious, and caution was for other men. He told himself the report was true in the ways that mattered, and the videos did not show the whole afternoon. He told himself the girl had made the stop hard, and he had only done what the job required. Each reason sounded weaker than the last, but he wrote anyway, finishing the last lines and signing his name at the bottom. He folded the pages, put them in an envelope, and drove to the station with the envelope on the seat beside him.
At the station the desk was quiet, and the officer on duty took the envelope without comment and stamped it with the time. The stamp showed eight in the evening. Mallerie watched the stamp come down and felt a brief relief, as if filing had settled something. He drove home by the long way and did not look toward the corner. At home he sat in the dark kitchen, and the relief did not last. He thought about the call from Dwire, and understood, too late to change it, that the report was now part of the record, and it would be read beside the body camera log, the dash camera, the radio call, and the two videos. The words he had written would not stand alone.
That night, in the Brooks house, Simone did not know the report had been filed. She would learn of it later, through the proper channels, and add it to the folder with the photographs, the clinic notes and the preservation letter. For now she slept lightly, listening for Aaliyah in the next room, while Mallerie's report sat in a tray at the station, stamped and filed, waiting for the morning. The report said one thing. The pictures said another. The distance between the two would become the heart of the case.
Chapter Twenty One
The Forty One Seconds