THE GIRL AGAINST THE PATROL CAR: THE CORNER, THE CAMERA, AND THE MOTHER HE NEVER ASKED ABOUT

Chapter 33

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

In the weeks before the trial, Gavin Sloan filed motion after motion, each one typed neatly, each one argued in careful language, each one aimed at a different piece of the evidence that had built up, piece by piece, since the afternoon at the corner. He asked the court to exclude the videos. He asked the court to exclude the body camera recording. He asked the court to exclude the messages Mallerie had sent. He asked the court to exclude the stop data and the analysis that Priya Shaww had prepared.

The hearing on the motions took place in a courtroom that felt smaller than the one where the trial would be held, with fewer people in the benches and a colder light coming through the high windows. Simone sat in the gallery with Aaliyah, in the same kind of seat she would occupy at the trial, and she kept her hands folded in her lap and her face calm. Aaliyah sat beside her and listened, trying to follow the arguments, and Simone explained the hard words to her afterward in whispers, so the hearing became a lesson as well as a proceeding. The judge would listen to both sides and decide what the jury was allowed to see and hear.

He said the video Malik had filmed was short, and taken from an angle, and did not show the whole encounter from the beginning. He said the second video, the one Dana had filmed, was longer, but it too had been filmed by a witness with feelings about what she had seen, and feelings could shape what a camera seemed to show. He said the body camera recording was only forty one seconds long, and that forty one seconds of sound, without the minutes before and after, could not carry the weight the prosecution wanted to put on it. He said the messages were private words, sent in the heat of a difficult day, and that private words should not be used to prove what a man had done in the street.

Daniel Cho answered him, and he answered without raising his voice, laying out the record piece by piece, the way a person lays out tools on a table before beginning a job. They were recordings made at the time, by people who had been there, and they matched each other, and they matched the dash camera, and they matched the signal data, and they matched the marks on the girl's body. He said the body camera recording was short because Mallerie himself had switched the camera off by hand, and that a man could not complain that the recording was short when he was the one who had made it short. They were words Mallerie had sent to his supervisor within the hour, describing the girl and the stop in his own language, and they showed what he had been thinking while the afternoon was still fresh. It was offered to show a pattern, a habit of stopping, a habit of wording, a habit that had repeated itself fourteen times in the files, and that pattern helped the jury understand what had happened at the corner.

The judge listened to both men without interrupting, taking notes in a steady hand, asking a question now and then that cut straight to the heart of the matter. The judge asked Sloan whether he disputed that the videos showed the corner, the cruiser, the girl and the officer, and Sloan said he did not dispute that much. The judge asked whether he disputed that the body camera had been switched off by hand, and Sloan said his client did not recall switching it off, which was not the same as a denial, and the courtroom went very still at the careful wording. The judge asked Cho whether the prosecution intended to show the jury every video in full, and Cho said yes, in full, with time for the defense to argue about each one, because the prosecution had nothing to hide in the footage.

When the rulings came, they came in the judge's plain voice, without flourish. The videos would be shown. The body camera recording would be played. The messages would be admitted, with the jury told to weigh them for what they showed about state of mind. The stop data would be admitted, with the analyst allowed to explain it, and the defense allowed to challenge it. The heart of the record stayed in. Aaliyah felt her mother's hand close over hers under the bench, and she felt a breath go out of her that she had not known she was holding. Simone leaned close and whispered that this was how the law was supposed to work, slowly and in the open, with both sides heard, and that the judge had done the job well.

Outside, on the courthouse steps, the cold air hit their faces, and Aaliyah pulled her coat closer. Reporters stood at a distance, and Leela Monroe was among them, notebook in hand, watching without pushing forward. Simone steered Aaliyah past them with a polite nod and no comment, and they walked to the car in silence. In the car, Aaliyah asked whether Sloan would try again at the trial to keep the videos out. Simone said he might argue about them again, in front of the jury, but the judge had ruled, and the rulings would stand, and the jury would see what had happened at the corner, from the cameras that had been there.

Chapter Thirty Four

The Courtroom in Winter

News in the same category

THE GIRL AGAINST THE PATROL CAR: THE CORNER, THE CAMERA, AND THE MOTHER HE NEVER ASKED ABOUT

45 Part