THE GIRL AGAINST THE PATROL CAR: THE CORNER, THE CAMERA, AND THE MOTHER HE NEVER ASKED ABOUT

Chapter 35

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The morning Aaliyah took the stand, she woke before her alarm, in the dark, and lay still for a while listening to the house. She thought about the corner, and about the courtroom, and about the difference between remembering a thing in your own room and saying it aloud in front of strangers. She got up and dressed slowly, choosing the same plain dark dress she had worn for the opening, and she braided her hair with care, the way her mother had taught her, pulling each section smooth. At breakfast she ate little, a piece of toast, a glass of juice, and Simone did not press her to eat more.

In the courtroom, Daniel Cho called her name, and the clerk swore her in, and she walked to the witness stand with her back straight and her hands at her sides. She sat down, and the chair creaked, and she looked out at the jury, twelve faces watching her with a kindness that steadied her more than she had expected. She looked at her mother in the gallery, second row, and Simone nodded once, small and sure, and Aaliyah nodded back, and then she turned to Cho, who stood a little way off, his voice calm, his questions simple, one at a time, giving her room to answer in her own words.

She told them about the pharmacy, and the paper sack, and the book, and the bottle of water, and the heat of the afternoon. She told them about the walk signal, and the cruiser past the stop line, and the voice calling out to her to stop. She told them about raising her hands, and how they had trembled, and about saying she had done nothing, because she had done nothing. She told them about the hand closing around her wrist, and the pull toward the cruiser, and the push against the hot metal, and the pain in her arm and her shoulder and her face, and the way she had asked for her mother, again and again, because her mother was the person she wanted when she was hurt and afraid. She spoke slowly, and she did not hurry, and when she came to the moment when she had said her mother worked for the government, her voice held steady, and she said the words again, plainly, for the record.

Cho asked her whether she had run, and she said no. He asked whether she had fought, and she said no. He asked whether she had swung at the officer, and she said no, she had not, and her hands had been up, and she had been trying to do as she was told. He asked her to point to the man who had stopped her, and she lifted her hand, and pointed across the room, at Trent Mallerie, sitting at the far table in his dark suit, and she said, in a clear voice, that he was the man. Mallerie did not look up. Sloan wrote something on a pad.

The cross examination came after a short break, and Sloan rose with a manner that was polite on the surface and sharp underneath. He asked her whether she remembered every second of the afternoon, exactly, without mistake, and she said she remembered what had happened, and that some small details had faded, and she would say so when they had. He asked whether she might have moved suddenly, in a way that looked like lunging, and she said no, she had stood still, with her hands up, and she knew the difference. He asked whether she had swung her arm, perhaps without meaning to, and she said no, she had not swung at anyone, and she knew what she had done with her hands, because she had been watching them herself, willing them to stay still.

Sloan asked her about the videos, and whether she had watched them, and she said she had watched them once, with her mother, and that watching them had been hard, and she had not watched them again. He asked whether the videos had shaped her memory, whether she was remembering the films rather than the afternoon, and she said no, she remembered the afternoon itself, the heat, the metal, the voice, and the films only showed what she already knew. He asked her, at last, whether she was angry, and she thought about the question, honestly, before she answered, because it deserved an honest answer. She said she had been angry, and frightened, and that she still felt both sometimes, but that she was not there to be angry. She was there to tell what had happened, so that it would not happen to another child at another corner, and she meant that, and the room was very quiet when she finished.

When she stepped down from the stand, her legs felt unsteady, and she was glad of her mother's hand on her arm in the hallway, and glad of the bottle of water Simone pressed into her hand. Jordan was waiting near the doors with a quiet word of praise, and Dana was there too, and she hugged Aaliyah gently, careful of her shoulder, and said she had done well. Aaliyah nodded, and she felt the tiredness come over her all at once, the tiredness of months of waiting and a morning of telling, and she leaned against her mother for a moment, and breathed, and let the courthouse noise wash around her.

Chapter Thirty Six

The Witnesses Who Filmed and Measured

News in the same category

THE GIRL AGAINST THE PATROL CAR: THE CORNER, THE CAMERA, AND THE MOTHER HE NEVER ASKED ABOUT

45 Part