The judge spoke to the jury in the late afternoon, in words that were careful and even, and told them what the law asked of them. The charge under 18 U.S.C. section 242 asked whether Mallerie, acting under color of law, had willfully deprived Aaliyah Brooks of her rights by using excessive force, knowing that what he did was wrong. The second count asked whether he had falsified records by filing a report he knew to be untrue. The third count asked whether he had obstructed the investigation by switching off the camera and by changing the file. The judge told them to weigh each count on its own, to set aside sympathy and anger, and to decide only on the evidence they had seen and heard. The jury filed out in a line, twelve people carrying notebooks, and the courtroom emptied slowly behind them, with Simone and Aaliyah sitting together on a bench in the corridor, saying little. The waiting began, and it had the strange quality of all waiting after a long trial, both too quiet and too loud at once.
Inside the jury room, the first hour went to the films. One juror asked for the 73 seconds to be played again, and the bailiff brought in the equipment, and the room watched in silence as the girl raised her hands and the officer took her wrist. Another juror asked for Dana's film, and they watched the cruiser across the crosswalk and the walk signal glowing, and the push against the side of the car. A third juror asked for the camera log to be read aloud, and the foreperson read the start time, the 41 seconds, and the hand on the switch, slowly, twice. They talked about the difference between a camera failing and a camera being switched off, and they agreed, without much argument, that the log left no room for an accident. They talked about the radio call at 3:19, and how it came after the push, and how a report written at 8 in the evening could not make a threat appear where the films showed none.
The second and third hours went to the witnesses. They went over Dana's testimony, and how she had stood at the crosswalk and seen the whole thing, and how she had no reason to invent it. They went over Malik's testimony, and how a seventeen year old had kept the original film and sent it to the investigators the same evening. They went over Marcus and the seal, and how the record had been kept whole once it was sealed, which meant the gaps had been made before the seal, not after. They went over Dwire last, because his testimony had been the hardest to hear, and they talked about a supervisor who had approved reports without checking them, and who had warned a subordinate about the record, and who had come back late to tell the truth.
By the fourth hour they had turned to the counts. On the first count, the force, they weighed the age of the girl, twelve, against the size of the officer and the heat of the metal, and they weighed the raised hands against the claims of refusal and flight. They found no run, no blow, no threat in any film, and they found the push plain and hard. On the second count, the records, they weighed the report filed at 8 in the evening against the films, and they found the claims of lunging and swinging nowhere in the record, and they found the missing pages, the force analysis, the scene map, the discipline history, and the audit log that showed the file had been opened and changed. On the third count, the obstruction, they weighed the switched off camera and the changed file together, and they found a deliberate effort to shape the record after the fact. They did not rush. They sent a note asking for the indictment to be read again, and they sent another asking for the definition of willfulness, and the judge answered both in open court, while the lawyers listened and the gallery held its breath.
The deliberations stretched into a second afternoon, and the hours added up to nine. Aaliyah spent the first afternoon in the corridor with her mother, drawing in a notebook, and the second afternoon at school, where Jordan walked beside her in the hall and said nothing about the trial unless she raised it. Simone spent the hours answering no calls from the department, as she had been told, and keeping her phone close for the call from the court. Mallerie spent the hours with his lawyer, going over the same ground, saying little. The city waited too, in its own way, with the Chronicle running a short piece each morning and the council saying nothing until the verdict came. When the note arrived, saying the jury had reached a verdict, the courtroom filled in minutes, and the air went tight. The foreperson stood, and the clerk read the verdicts one by one. On the first count, guilty. On the second count, guilty. On the third count, guilty. Aaliyah did not cry. She reached for her mother's hand, and Simone held it, and outside the courtroom, in the winter light, the two of them stood together while the reporters waited at a distance, and the nine hours of careful weighing settled into three words that would follow Mallerie for the rest of his life.
Chapter Forty
The Sentence of Fifty Four Months