THE GIRL AGAINST THE PATROL CAR: THE CORNER, THE CAMERA, AND THE MOTHER HE NEVER ASKED ABOUT

Chapter 40

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The sentencing hearing took place in the same courtroom, with Aaliyah sitting in the gallery beside her mother. The judge entered, and the room rose, and the proceedings began with the reading of the verdicts, guilty on all three counts, and with the presentation of the reports that would guide the sentence. Daniel Cho spoke first for the prosecution, and he did not ask for anger. He asked for a sentence that matched the record, and he laid the record out once more, in order, without raising his voice. He spoke of a twelve year old girl walking home from a pharmacy on a hot July afternoon, carrying a paper sack, a bag, a book and a bottle of water. He spoke of a cruiser past the stop line, a walk signal on, hands raised, a wrist taken, a push against hot metal. He spoke of a camera switched off by hand after 41 seconds, a radio call at 3:19, a report filed at 8 in the evening that said the girl had lunged and swung, and a file that came to the investigators missing its force analysis, its scene map and its discipline history. He said the sentence had to say that a badge does not make a false record true, and that a child with her hands up is not a threat because an officer says she is. He sat down, and the room was quiet.

Gavin Sloan spoke for Mallerie, and he asked for mercy, and he spoke of seven years of service, of a family at home, of a man who had made a grave mistake in a moment of pressure and who would carry the verdict for the rest of his life. Mallerie stood when the judge invited him to speak, and he said he was sorry, and that he had not meant for it to go this far, and that he thought of his wife and children and of the life he had lost.

The judge spoke last, and the judge spoke slowly, choosing each word with care. The judge said the case was not about a difficult stop or a hard day, but about a child who had done nothing wrong and an officer who had used force she did not need, and who had then tried to shape the record to hide it. The judge said the films had shown the truth, and the witnesses had confirmed it, and the jury had believed it, and the sentence had to honor that belief. The judge said the law gave room for mercy, and that mercy had been weighed, but that mercy could not erase the harm to a twelve year old girl, or the harm to the public trust when an officer writes a false report and switches off a camera. The judge said the sentence would reflect both the force and the falsehood, because the two could not be separated, and because a community that cannot trust the record cannot trust the badge. The judge paused, and the room held still, and then the sentence was pronounced, in plain terms that left no doubt about what would follow.

Mallerie was sentenced to 54 months in federal prison. He would serve the term in full, under the rules of the federal system, and he would then serve three years of supervised release, reporting as directed and living under the conditions the court set. He was banned from law enforcement work, so that he would never again hold the authority he had misused at the corner of South Main Street and Cedar Avenue. He was banned from owning weapons, so that the power he had carried on that afternoon would not return to his hands. He was ordered to pay Aaliyah's medical costs, the clinic visits, the examinations, the treatment and the follow up care that had followed the stop, so that the family would not carry the financial weight of an injury they had not caused. The judge said the sentence was not vengeance, but a measure of what the law required when a public trust had been broken, and when a child had been hurt and then blamed for her own hurt.

When the sentence was pronounced, Mallerie stood, and the officers moved to his side, and the handcuffs were fastened in front of the courtroom, with a quiet click that seemed louder than it was. He turned once toward his wife and children, and he said he was sorry, and that he had not meant for it to go this far, and then he was led through the side door, and the door closed behind him. Simone and Aaliyah remained seated for a moment after the room began to empty, and Simone put an arm around her daughter, and Aaliyah leaned into it, and neither of them spoke. Outside, in the corridor, Simone told Aaliyah that the sentence would not undo the afternoon, and that it would not take away the marks or the fear, but that it said, in the language of the law, that the truth had been believed. Aaliyah nodded, and she asked whether it was over, and Simone said the trial was over, and that the rest, the healing and the walking past the corner and the playing again, would take its own time. They walked out together into the winter air, and the sentence of fifty four months stood behind them, a number that measured the distance between a push against hot metal and the long work of making it right.

Chapter Forty One

The Door That Closed Behind Him

News in the same category

THE GIRL AGAINST THE PATROL CAR: THE CORNER, THE CAMERA, AND THE MOTHER HE NEVER ASKED ABOUT

45 Part