Chapter Eight
The Things That Fell
The things fell all at once, and the sound they made was small and ordinary against the noise of the street. The paper sack hit the pavement first and tipped onto its side. The book slid out and landed face down, its pages bending. The bottle of water rolled a short way and stopped against the curb. The bag she had carried over her shoulder slipped down her arm and dropped beside her feet, its strap tangling around her ankle. She heard each small sound separately, the way a person hears rain on a roof, one drop at a time, and each one made the afternoon feel more real and more wrong. She had carried those things out of the pharmacy only minutes earlier, neat and ordinary, and now they were scattered on the hot pavement like litter.
Mallerie did not pick them up. He did not step back to give her room to reach them. He kept his hold on her wrist and told her to gather her things, as if the mess on the ground were her own doing and her own responsibility to fix. She stared down at the sack, lying on its side with its top folded over, the small purchases she had chosen with care now pressed against the dirty pavement. She wanted to kneel and set them right, to smooth the sack and put the book back inside it. But she could not kneel while he held her against the car, and she could not reach the bottle without pulling away, and pulling away was the one thing she feared to do. Any sudden movement might be read as an attempt to run, and she had already been accused of enough things she had not done.
He repeated the order, sharper this time, and loosened his grip just enough that she could bend, awkwardly, with one hand still caught. She crouched down, keeping her shoulder near the car, and reached for the sack with her free hand. The pavement burned her knees through her clothes. The sack was light and crumpled, and she held it against her chest for a moment, as if holding it close could undo the last few minutes. Then she reached for the book. Its cover was scuffed and one corner was bent, and she brushed the dust off it with her palm, carefully, the way she would brush dirt off a friend's jacket. The bottle had rolled just beyond her reach. She stretched for it, her fingers closing around the cool plastic, and she set it upright beside her foot, grateful for the small, solid weight of it in her hand.
The bag was the hardest. Its strap had looped around her ankle, and when she tried to lift it, the strap pulled tight and she stumbled a half step sideways. Mallerie steadied her with a hand on her arm, not gently, and told her to hurry. She freed the strap with clumsy fingers, her hands shaking so badly that the simple task took three tries. She hated how clumsy she felt. At school she was quick and sure handed, good at catching a basketball. Now her fingers would not obey her. At last the strap came free, and she slung the bag over her shoulder again, feeling its familiar weight settle, feeling a fraction more like herself.
All the while, a voice kept speaking from the crosswalk. Dana stood at the edge of the road, not coming closer, not backing away, saying plainly and steadily that the girl had done nothing wrong. She said it more than once, in the same even tone, as if repetition might eventually get through. She said Aaliyah's hands had been up before anyone touched her. She said the girl had been walking in the crosswalk, with the signal on, minding her own business. She said the cruiser was the thing blocking the way, not the child. Her voice did not shake. It carried over the traffic sounds, calm and certain. It was the first adult voice since the stop began that was on her side, and Aaliyah clung to it.
Mallerie turned toward Dana and told her to step back, to mind her own business and let him do his job. Dana did not step back. She stayed at the edge of the crosswalk and said again that she had seen the whole thing from the start, that she had watched Aaliyah cross with the signal, and that she had heard the girl answer politely. Aaliyah, crouched on the pavement with her sack in her arms, felt a surge of gratitude so large it crowded out the fear for a moment. Someone had seen. Someone was saying so, out loud, where it could be heard. She was not invisible. The afternoon was not only his version of events.
She finished gathering her things and stood up slowly, holding the sack against her chest with both arms, the book tucked under one elbow, the bag on her shoulder, the bottle in her hand. She stood there, small and loaded down, in the heat, waiting to be told what would happen next. The pavement still shimmered. The cruiser still blocked the crosswalk. But the things that had fallen were back in her hands, and the woman at the crosswalk was still speaking, and for the first time since the cruiser pulled up, Aaliyah felt the faintest loosening of the knot in her chest, the first hint that this story might have more than one witness.