THE GIRL AGAINST THE PATROL CAR: THE CORNER, THE CAMERA, AND THE MOTHER HE NEVER ASKED ABOUT

Chapter 34

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Winter came to Baltimore in earnest the week the trial opened, with a cold wind off the water and a sky the color of old pewter, and the courthouse steps were salted against ice in the early morning. Aaliyah arrived with her mother just as the light was coming up, and the building looked different in the winter, harder and more formal, as if the season had stripped away anything soft. She wore a plain dark dress and a coat that buttoned to the throat, and her braids fell to her shoulders, longer than they had been in July, and she walked up the steps with her feet flat and steady, the way the therapist had taught her, noticing the weight of each step. Simone walked beside her, in her plain coat, her hand resting lightly on her daughter's back, saying nothing, because there was nothing left to say that had not already been said in the months of waiting.

Inside, the air was warm, and the courtroom filled slowly, bench by bench, with reporters, with observers, with the families of witnesses, and with the quiet rustle of coats being folded and papers being set in order. Aaliyah sat in the gallery for the opening, beside her mother, and she looked around the room with the careful attention of a person who has learned to notice details. The jury sat in two rows, twelve men and women of different ages, with notebooks on their laps and faces that gave nothing away. At the other table sat Gavin Sloan and Trent Mallerie, and Mallerie wore a dark suit and kept his hands folded on the table, and he did not look toward the gallery. Aaliyah looked at him once, and then looked away, and fixed her eyes on the seal on the wall, and breathed in and out, until her heartbeat slowed to something she could live with.

When Daniel Cho rose to open the case, the room went quiet in the way rooms go quiet when everyone knows the next words matter. He spoke plainly, as if he were telling a story to people who deserved the whole of it, without decoration and without hurry. He began with the afternoon itself, a hot day in July, a girl of twelve walking home from a pharmacy with a paper sack and a book and a bottle of water, crossing at the corner of South Main Street and Cedar Avenue. He described the walk signal, on, with seventeen seconds left, a lawful crossing, a girl doing nothing more than walking home. He described the cruiser, past the stop line, blocking the crosswalk, and the officer who stepped out and ordered the girl to stop, and to show her hands, and to give her name. He described the hands, already up, trembling, and the wrist taken hold of, and the push against the side of the cruiser, hot from the sun, and the face pressed to the metal, and the voice asking for her mother.

The body camera, he said, had run for forty one seconds, and then it had been switched off by hand, before the officer touched the girl. He described the videos that followed, the seventy three seconds filmed by a seventeen year old at the corner, the three minutes and forty eight seconds filmed by an older woman who had stood at the crosswalk and refused to look away, and the dash camera that had watched without sound. He said the videos matched each other, and the signal data matched the videos, and the pharmacy receipt matched the time, and the marks on the girl's wrist and shoulder and face matched what the videos showed.

The written report, filed at eight in the evening, said the girl had lunged and swung at the officer, had refused every command, had tried to flee. The videos showed a girl with her hands up. The camera log showed a camera switched off. The messages showed an officer describing the girl in dismissive terms within the hour. The files showed fourteen complaints, and six describing the same pattern, and a supervisor who had cleared them all. Cho said the jury would have to decide what to believe, and he trusted them to believe the record, because the record had been made at the time, by machines and by strangers, before anyone knew whose daughter the girl was, and the record did not change its story to suit anyone.

Sloan rose next, and his opening was shorter, and careful in a different way. He said his client had acted in good faith, believing the girl was about to run, believing the situation required control, using only the smallest force he judged necessary. He said the videos did not show the whole story, that a camera saw only what it was pointed at, and that the jury should remember the officer had a split second to decide, on a hot afternoon, in a busy street. He asked them to listen to his client when he took the stand, and to weigh his account with fairness. He sat down, and the room was quiet again, and Aaliyah felt her mother's hand find hers, and she held on, and the trial began in earnest, with the first witness called, and the winter light coming thin and pale through the high windows, and the long road from the corner at last arriving at the place where the truth would be spoken aloud.

Chapter Thirty Five

The Girl on the Stand

News in the same category

THE GIRL AGAINST THE PATROL CAR: THE CORNER, THE CAMERA, AND THE MOTHER HE NEVER ASKED ABOUT

45 Part