THE GIRL AGAINST THE PATROL CAR: THE CORNER, THE CAMERA, AND THE MOTHER HE NEVER ASKED ABOUT

Chapter 27

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The file that reached the FBI did not match the file Rosa Mendes had guarded. The original audit log had run to twenty seven pages. The file handed over for the federal review ran to twenty four pages. Three pages were missing, and they were not blank pages,. They were the pages that explained what had happened at the corner, how much force had been used, where each person had stood, and how the department had handled the officer before.

Rosa found out about the shorter file the way she found out about most things in that building, by being asked to check a copy against her own records. An agent called her, read out the page count, and asked whether the number was right. She opened her notebook, found the entry she had made on the morning she sealed the log, and read the number back. Twenty seven pages. She asked the agent to read the list of sections in the file he held. He read them slowly, and Rosa marked each one in her notebook as he spoke. When he finished, three sections were unmarked. The force analysis was gone. The scene map was gone. The discipline history was gone.

The force analysis had set out,, what kind of contact had taken place, how long it had lasted, and what marks it had left. It was the part of the file that turned a complaint into a matter of record, because it tied the words of the witnesses to the marks on the girl and to the pictures taken that afternoon. Without it, the file read as if the stop had been a conversation that went wrong, and not a use of force against a child who had her hands up. Rosa knew that difference mattered, and she said so, plainly, when the agent asked her what the missing pages had contained.

The scene map had shown the corner of South Main Street and Cedar Avenue as it had been that afternoon. It had shown the stop line, the crosswalk, the cruiser past the line, the walk signal, the pharmacy on one side, and the places where Dana and Malik had stood. It had shown, in a single drawing, the facts that the videos showed in motion. Without the map, a reader had to take the words of the report on trust, and the report had already proved that it could not be trusted. Rosa had kept a copy of the map in her own drawer, made on the day the file was first put together,.

The discipline history had listed the fourteen complaints against Mallerie, the dates on which they had been made, the pattern they shared, and the outcomes that had followed each one. It had shown, in one place, that the same sergeant had cleared the same officer again and again, and that no discipline had followed any of the complaints. Without that history, Mallerie looked like an officer with a single bad afternoon, and not like an officer whose conduct had been questioned for years. Rosa understood why someone would want that history gone. She also understood that wanting it gone did not make it gone, because the audit log still showed that it had been there.

The agents asked Rosa to bring everything she had kept. She brought her notebook, her copies of the log, her copy of the map, and the list she had made of the sections in the original file. She sat at a table in the field office and went through the two files side by side, page by page, with an agent beside her, marking each difference in pencil. At the end of it, the agent wrote out a short statement of what had been found, and Rosa read it, corrected one date, and signed it. The statement said that the file given to the FBI was three pages shorter than the original, and it named the three missing sections, and it gave the times at which the file had been opened and changed.

That evening, Rosa drove home later than usual.That evening Rosa she thought about the girl who had walked home from the pharmacy with a sack in her arms, and about the mother who had spent the evening photographing marks on her daughter instead of cooking supper. She thought about the fourteen complaints, and about the people who had made them, and about how it must have felt to be told, each time, that nothing had been found. She did not know all of their names. She knew that their files had been kept in the same room where she worked, and that she had a duty to those files that was larger than her duty to any one person in the building.

The next morning, the missing pages became part of the federal case. They were listed, by name, in the papers that followed, and the fact that they had been removed became a fact in its own right, separate from the stop itself. Rosa went back to her desk, opened the cabinet, and checked the remaining files one by one, to be sure that nothing else had been taken. Nothing else was missing. She wrote that down too, Then she closed the cabinet, locked it, and put the key in her pocket, and she went on with the work of the day, keeping the records whole, one page at a time.

Chapter Twenty Eight

The Council Meeting and the Resignation

News in the same category

THE GIRL AGAINST THE PATROL CAR: THE CORNER, THE CAMERA, AND THE MOTHER HE NEVER ASKED ABOUT

45 Part