Grace Halden, Northgate's general counsel, who had arrived with Reid and who had been reading Selma's note over a lawyer's shoulder, spoke then, quietly and clearly. "Mr. Reid," she said, "a warranty in a contract is a remedy after a failure. It is not a substitute for verification before signing. If the summary is wrong about title and certification, the warranty does not make it right. It only gives us someone to sue afterward, and a lawsuit afterward is not a deal."
Reid turned to her, and for a moment his composure slipped, and Selma saw the man underneath the performance: a man who had built his reputation on moving quickly, who had told his board that this deal would close, who had promised a signing in the morning, and who was now standing in a room where the morning had a different plan. "I can provide the underlying records within two hours," he said. "The Institute's position, the lab's report, all of it. Give me two hours."
Han considered. "We will wait two hours for more information," he said. "We do not promise to sign after two hours. We promise to read what you bring."
Reid left, with Halden beside him, and the room exhaled, the way a room exhales when a storm has passed over it without breaking anything. Chairman Han sat down again, and he said to his team, in Korean and then in English, that they must be careful to distinguish what they suspected from what they could prove, and that the record must show that Selma was not responsible for a decision that belonged to directors. Selma wrote that down too, because it was the kindest thing anyone in a position of power had ever said about her in a room full of power, and she wanted to remember the exact words.
She left the law office before the two hours were up, because her part was done and because she had a shift at the restaurant that evening, and because she had learned that the best way to keep a clear head was to go back to work that had nothing to do with millions of dollars. She walked along the waterfront in the October light, with the ferries moving across the bay and the gulls crying over the piers, and she thought about how strange it was that a footnote, printed smaller than the words around it, could stop a three-hundred-and-eighty-million-dollar deal in its tracks. It was not strange, she decided. It was the way things were supposed to work. Small words held large weights. That was why her grandmother had taught her to read them carefully.
While Selma was walking along the waterfront, Aaron Kline was sitting in a private room at Northgate's offices with Cormac Reid, and the conversation between them was the kind that only happens between two men who have worked together for fourteen years and who have run out of polite ways to avoid a subject. Kline had the summary on the table in front of him, and Selma's note beside it, and a printout of the public filing about Pacific Test Labs that Jack Corbin had found.
"Explain this to me," Kline said. "Not the deal. Not the strategy. This. The summary says independent certification. The lab is funded by our venture arm. The summary says unencumbered title. The patent is licensed, and the license runs out in eighteen months, and nobody asked the Institute for consent. If the independent report was still outstanding, why does the summary read as though it were in hand?"
Reid did not answer at once. He stood at the window, looking out at the city he had helped build in his own mind, a city of towers and deals and decisive men, and when he turned back, his face was tired in a way Selma had never seen it. "I did not write the summary," he said. "I read it. I trusted it. I believed the remaining work was administrative. I believed the team when they said the work was essentially done."
"Believing is not verifying," Kline said. "You are the chief executive. You told the board this would close. You told Hanbit it would close. You told the press, in so many words, that it would close. And now a server from a restaurant has found, in a footnote, what our own review missed. Do you understand what that looks like?"
"I understand what it looks like," Reid said. "I also understand what it is. I did not invent a report. I did not tell anyone to invent a report. I accepted a summary that described certification as complete, and I did not ask to see the final document, because I trusted the people who prepared it and because I wanted the deal to move. That is carelessness, Aaron. I will not pretend it is something else, and I will not pretend it is nothing."