When I was appointed, and then confirmed, and then sworn in, I thought of that evening on the bench outside the courtroom. I thought of it not sentimentally, but as a matter of record. The oath I took did not erase the memory of the cart, the marble, the brass, the wastebaskets, or the floors. It added a layer to it. I now sit in a chair that is high so that people can see who is responsible for making the decision. I feel that height every time I enter the courtroom. It is not comfortable. It is not supposed to be. Comfort would be a sign that I had mistaken the chair for a privilege rather than an assignment. The height makes concealment difficult. It makes it harder to pretend a decision came from nowhere, or from the room, or from precedent alone without a human being choosing to apply it. I am that human being, for the cases on my docket, for the time I hold this office. That is the responsibility my mother was pointing to when she looked through the open door.
I still notice the building in the way she taught me to notice it, even though I now arrive in the morning rather than the evening, and even though I no longer walk beside a supply cart. I notice when a corridor floor has been freshly scrubbed, and I think, without stopping my stride, of the hands that scrubbed it before I arrived. I notice the brass fixtures, polished, catching the morning light in the same hard lines they caught in the evening light when I was eight. I notice the wastebaskets, lined and empty, waiting for the day. I notice the offices, some of them now occupied by people I know by name, and some of them still occupied by people who pass the cleaning staff without learning their names. I have made it a practice, small and deliberate, to learn those names when I can, and to greet the people who maintain this building as people rather than as functions. It is not a grand gesture. It does not change the structure of the institution. But it is a correction to a blindness I was raised to see, and I do not think small corrections are beneath a judge. A courtroom that cannot see the people who prepare it is a courtroom that risks not seeing other people, too.
There are evenings, even now, when I stay late, and the building begins to empty in the familiar way. Attorneys gather their files. Clerks shut down their computers. The corridors lose their daytime noise and take on that hollow evening sound I first learned as a child. On those evenings, I sometimes hear a cart in a distant corridor, and for a moment I am eight again, sitting on a wooden bench with a library book, waiting for my mother to come back down the hall. The feeling passes. I am not eight. I am the judge in the building my mother cleaned. But the continuity is not lost on me. The same marble carries both versions of me, the child who watched and the adult who decides, and the distance between them is measured not only in years but in the work my mother described: study, work, learning the law, and remembering to hear people.
That memory has become, over time, a standard I apply to myself before I apply the law to anyone else. When a witness hesitates on the stand, I do not immediately interpret the hesitation as evasion. I consider whether the witness is afraid, and of what, and whether the courtroom itself, with its height and its formality and its audience, is contributing to that fear. When a party's account is incomplete, I do not immediately fill the gap with my own theory. I ask what has not been said, and who might know it, and whether that person has been given a reason to believe that speaking will be safe. When an officer testifies, I listen for precision, not for confidence alone, because confidence is easy to perform and precision is harder to fake. When a lawyer argues, I listen for what the argument omits as well as for what it asserts. These are not rules of evidence. They are habits of attention, learned first in a corridor at night, from a woman who cleaned rooms and watched how people behaved when they thought no one important was watching.
My mother is no longer cleaning these corridors in the evenings, but her standard remains in the building for me, in the polished brass and the scrubbed floors and the empty wastebaskets that greet me each morning. I carry her question, and my own unanswered question, into every proceeding: who is responsible, who deserves to be heard, and what will it cost the person who speaks to speak truthfully here. Those are not questions I can answer in the abstract. I can only answer them case by case, hearing by hearing, decision by decision, by sitting where I can be seen and by owning what I decide.