When I came out, the corridor had changed in the way corridors change when procedure takes hold. Voss and Pruitt were no longer in the same space. Mercer had separated them before I finished with the paramedics, and I did not see where either man had been taken, which was correct. Separation is not punishment. It is the precondition for truthful accounts, and it protects the officers as much as it protects anyone else, because two men who cannot compare notes cannot later be accused of having done so. Mercer told me only that each was with a different deputy, that neither had been left alone with the other, and that neither would be permitted to return to the basement level until the area had been documented. I did not ask for more detail than that. I did not need to direct his work. He knew it, and my interference would have weakened it.
Equipment was the next matter, and I watched Mercer handle it with the same restraint. He did not permit anyone to tidy the corridor. The bench stayed where it was. The door to the records office stayed as it had been left. He asked the deputies to note the position of every item before anything was moved, and to photograph what could be photographed without altering it. Radios, keys, and any duty equipment belonging to the officers were logged and held, not confiscated in a theatrical sense but preserved, with a written receipt for each item and a note of who had held it and when. I was asked to account for my own belongings in the same way. My robe was still upstairs in chambers. My phone was in my bag, which had been left in the corridor during the incident. Mercer logged it, sealed it in an envelope in my presence, and recorded that no one had opened it. I appreciated the symmetry of that. A process that treats the judge differently from the officers is not a process at all.
The recordings were the part I cared about most, because memory, even a judge's memory, is not a record. Mercer asked, systematically, what systems covered the lower level. There was fixed surveillance footage from cameras in the corridor and at the stairwell, and he secured it by the proper method, which was not to copy it onto a personal drive or to view it repeatedly in the hallway, but to place a formal preservation hold through courthouse security, to log the camera numbers and time stamps, and to ensure that the original files would be retained untouched while working copies were made for investigators. He did the same for access logs, for the elevator records, and for the sign-in sheet at the lower-level entrance, such as it was. Nothing was erased. Nothing was overwritten. The interval he preserved began well before the incident and ended well after it, because context matters and because a narrow clip invites the accusation that something was cut away.
Then there was Camille Ross. I had not known her name when I first heard the telephone in the records office, but Mercer knew the staffing roster for the clerk's office, and within minutes he had identified the staff member who had been working behind the frosted-glass door. Her name was Camille Ross. She was a clerk's office staff member, not a lawyer, not a deputy, not a person accustomed to being a witness in a federal matter. When Mercer brought her name to me, I did not ask to speak to her alone. That would have been the worst thing I could have done. Instead, I asked that she be treated as a witness, with the same protections and the same formality as any other witness, and that her account be taken by an investigator who was not me and not anyone who reported to me in the ordinary course of chambers business.
What Camille had done, without knowing at the time that it would matter so much, was to leave a telephone recording. In the records office, she had been on a call when the sounds from the corridor reached her, and the call had continued, and the recording system for that line had captured more than either party to the call had intended to preserve. It was not a secret recording made for drama. It was an ordinary office system doing what ordinary office systems do, and for that reason it carried a weight that testimony alone rarely carries. It was objective. It did not shake. It did not forget the order of events. Mercer secured it through the clerk's office, with a written request, a logged retrieval, and a duplicate made under supervision, so that the original would remain with the system of record and the investigation would work from a verified copy. I did not listen to it in the corridor. I did not need to hear my own voice played back to know what had happened, and listening to it prematurely, outside the investigation, would have created exactly the kind of contamination I was trying to prevent.