THEY DRAGGED A HELPLESS WOMAN INTO THE COURTHOUSE BASEMENT AND TRIED TO CUT OFF HER HAIR, NOT KNOWING SHE WAS THE FEDERAL JUDGE ASSIGNED TO THEIR TRIAL IN TWENTY MINUTES

Chapter 6

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Misconduct by public officials, as a category, taught me to be careful with language. I did not allege misconduct lightly, and I did not accept an allegation of misconduct from a client without testing it. A difficult encounter is not necessarily a constitutional violation. An officer who is rude has not necessarily acted unlawfully. A supervisor who makes a poor decision has not necessarily violated a right. The law draws lines, and my credibility as counsel depended on respecting those lines, even when a client's anger was justified in human terms but not sufficient in legal terms. That discipline was difficult, and it was necessary. If I overstated one case, I undermined the next case, and the next client, who might have a meritorious claim that would then be received with skepticism because of my earlier overstatement. Precision, I learned, is not pedantry. It is a form of advocacy, because a precise claim is harder to dismiss than a sweeping one.

That precision carried into my approach to witnesses. I prepared witnesses by explaining the process, not by scripting their answers. I told them they would be asked about inconsistencies, that they would be asked to recall details they might not remember, that they would be asked why they had not reported an event sooner, and that none of those questions, by itself, meant they were disbelieved. I told them to answer only what they knew, to distinguish between what they saw and what they concluded, and to say plainly when they did not remember. That last instruction was the hardest for many witnesses to follow, because saying "I do not remember" in a courtroom feels like failure. I explained that it is not failure. It is accuracy, and accuracy is more persuasive than a confident reconstruction that collapses under cross-examination. A witness who admits the limits of her memory is a witness a jury can trust on the matters she does remember.

I also prepared witnesses for the reality that their demeanor would be judged. I did not tell them to perform calmness they did not feel. I told them that nervousness is normal, that pausing to think is permissible, and that the court is accustomed to witnesses who are frightened. What I could not prepare them for, fully, was the experience of being disbelieved in a formal setting, of having a lawyer suggest, in measured language, that they were mistaken, or exaggerating, or motivated by grievance. Some witnesses withstood that experience. Some did not, and their testimony faltered not because it was false, but because the setting itself was hostile to the way they told the truth. I kept that observation in mind when I became a judge, and I made it a point to conduct my courtroom in a manner that did not add to that hostility. A witness should be tested, but testing does not require humiliation.

The transition to the bench did not erase those observations. It reframed them. As counsel, I advocated for one side. As a judge, I am responsible for the fairness of the proceeding itself. That responsibility includes ruling on motions to suppress, on objections, on the admissibility of evidence, and on the credibility of witnesses, but it also includes matters that do not appear in a ruling: the tone I set, the time I allow, the questions I ask to clarify rather than to trap, the findings I make on the record so that a reviewing court, and the parties, can understand my reasoning. I have tried, in these fourteen months, to write findings that are specific enough to be reviewed and honest enough to be useful. A conclusory ruling helps no one. A ruling that identifies the evidence relied upon, the testimony credited and why, and the legal standard applied, gives the losing party something to evaluate and, if necessary, to challenge. That is not a concession. It is the work of the court.

I have also learned, on the bench, how much depends on matters that never reach a written opinion. A scheduling decision can determine whether a witness is available. A ruling on the scope of discovery can determine whether a crucial document is produced. A decision to allow a brief recess can determine whether a witness composes herself enough to testify coherently. These are discretionary decisions, and they are rarely reversed, which is precisely why they require care. I do not pretend to make them perfectly. I try to make them deliberately, and to state my reasons, even briefly, so that the record reflects a decision rather than an impulse.

News in the same category

THEY DRAGGED A HELPLESS WOMAN INTO THE COURTHOUSE BASEMENT AND TRIED TO CUT OFF HER HAIR, NOT KNOWING SHE WAS THE FEDERAL JUDGE ASSIGNED TO THEIR TRIAL IN TWENTY MINUTES

45 Part