THEY DRAGGED A HELPLESS WOMAN INTO THE COURTHOUSE BASEMENT AND TRIED TO CUT OFF HER HAIR, NOT KNOWING SHE WAS THE FEDERAL JUDGE ASSIGNED TO THEIR TRIAL IN TWENTY MINUTES

Chapter 20

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

I used the interval to breathe and to reorient. My neck felt cold where the curls had been, a physical fact I registered without interpreting it. My shoulders ached from the position of the cuffs. My robe bag and my briefcase were outside, on the steps or in the service entrance, and my notes for the morning's testimony were in the briefcase. That loss mattered to me more, in a practical sense, than the hair did, because the notes were the work of the morning, and the morning was still supposed to happen. In twenty minutes, by my calculation, I was due to take the bench. In twenty minutes, the parties would be seated, the witness would be called, and the courtroom would wait for a judge who was instead standing in a basement room with her hands cuffed behind her back. That gap, between where I was supposed to be and where I was, was the real injury, larger than any single act in the room. It was a proceeding interrupted, a docket delayed, a public function prevented by private force.

I said so. I said, "In twenty minutes I am scheduled to preside. The officers scheduled to testify this morning are expected in my courtroom. If I am not there, the proceeding cannot go forward as scheduled, and the reason for that delay will be this detention." I said it because I wanted the connection stated plainly, while the men who had created the delay were still in the room to hear it. I did not know then that a clerk's office staff member, Camille Ross, was working in the records office behind the frosted-glass door in that same lower-level corridor, or that a telephone recording from that office would later preserve, in objective form, sounds from the corridor that no one in the room could control. I knew only that my voice was carrying, perhaps, through a door that was not as soundproof as they assumed, and that voices carry further in concrete corridors than people expect. I spoke, therefore, as if someone might hear me, because someone might, and because a judge speaks for the record even when she cannot see the record being made.

The shorter officer returned from the door and said the corridor was clear. The taller officer nodded and reached, not for the clippers again, but for something at his belt, and I understood from the movement of his hand that he was reaching for the handcuff key. I did not know whether he intended to remove the cuffs or to adjust them, to tighten them, to reposition them. I knew only the gesture, familiar from courtrooms, where an officer reaches for a key at the end of a proceeding, when restraints are no longer needed. Here, at the beginning of a proceeding that had not yet happened, the gesture meant something else, something unfinished. I watched his hand move. I kept my voice steady. I said, "State what you are doing, and why." I said it because every act in a proceeding must be stated, and because stating it forces the actor to own it.

He did not answer. His fingers found the key. The metal door of the room, which had been closed since we entered, was the only barrier between this room and the corridor, between what had happened inside and what might still happen outside. I had stopped expecting it to open. I had, in the way that people do when they have been in a closed room long enough, begun to accept the room as the whole world. That acceptance is dangerous, and I recognized it as dangerous even as I felt it. A closed room teaches you to lower your expectations to the size of the room. A judge must not do that. A judge must keep the larger world in mind, the courtroom upstairs, the docket, the law, even when the room is small.

News in the same category

THEY DRAGGED A HELPLESS WOMAN INTO THE COURTHOUSE BASEMENT AND TRIED TO CUT OFF HER HAIR, NOT KNOWING SHE WAS THE FEDERAL JUDGE ASSIGNED TO THEIR TRIAL IN TWENTY MINUTES

45 Part