THEY DRAGGED A HELPLESS WOMAN INTO THE COURTHOUSE BASEMENT AND TRIED TO CUT OFF HER HAIR, NOT KNOWING SHE WAS THE FEDERAL JUDGE ASSIGNED TO THEIR TRIAL IN TWENTY MINUTES

Chapter 42

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

I have also learned to be careful about what I claim for myself in this account. I did not emerge from this matter as a symbol. I emerged as a judge who still has a docket, who still has to rule on motions, who still has to listen to people I may find unpersuasive or even untruthful, and who must listen to them anyway. That is the work. The morning proceeding, twenty minutes after the basement, was not an aberration. It was the work in its most concentrated form: a trial on my docket, officers scheduled to testify, parties waiting for rulings that had nothing to do with my morning, and a judge required to set aside what had just happened to her in order to do what the case required. I do not recount that morning to suggest I performed it flawlessly. I recount it because it established the standard I then had to meet in my own matter. If I could require myself to separate personal experience from judicial duty in the courtroom, I could require the same separation in the investigation. If I expected litigants to accept adverse rulings because the process was fair, I had to accept a process in my own case that might not give me the outcome I would have chosen if I had been free to choose. Fairness, to be real, must bind the person invoking it.

When the investigation phase had run its course and the referrals and administrative matters were in motion, I found myself returning to the courthouse after hours, as I sometimes do when the building is quiet. I did not go to the basement. I went to the courtroom. I stood where I had stood as a child, and I looked at the chair behind the bench. It is not an imposing chair. It is worn in places. The leather has softened where many judges before me have sat, and the wood has the marks of use, not ceremony. My mother showed it to me as a place you do not just climb into, and for years I understood that as a warning about ambition. Do not seek the chair for status. Do not climb into it lightly. Do not treat it as a reward. I understand it now as something more precise. You do not just climb into the chair because the chair does not belong to the person sitting in it. It belongs to the people who will stand in front of it. It is held in trust for them, for the duration of a hearing, for the duration of a case, for the duration of a career. To sit in it is to accept that trust, and to accept that your own story, your own morning, your own fear, does not entitle you to reshape the proceeding to fit it.

I sat down, finally, in that quiet room, and I thought about my mother's answer and my eight-year-old question. Even if they're wrong? I had asked it as a child who thought wrongness might cancel the right to be heard. My life has taught me the answer my mother gave, but with the weight that only experience can add. Especially then. Especially when they are wrong, the people standing in front of me deserve to be heard. That is not because wrongness is excused by a hearing. It is because a hearing is how we determine wrongness reliably, rather than by assertion, by authority, by force, or by the fact that two officers agree and one person does not. If we only listen to those we already believe are right, we are not judging. We are ratifying. We are using the courtroom to confirm what power has already decided in a basement, in a corridor, in a place without a record. The hearing exists precisely for the person who may be wrong, because without it, there is no principled way to know that they are wrong, and no legitimate way to impose a consequence for being wrong.

News in the same category

THEY DRAGGED A HELPLESS WOMAN INTO THE COURTHOUSE BASEMENT AND TRIED TO CUT OFF HER HAIR, NOT KNOWING SHE WAS THE FEDERAL JUDGE ASSIGNED TO THEIR TRIAL IN TWENTY MINUTES

45 Part