THEY DRAGGED A HELPLESS WOMAN INTO THE COURTHOUSE BASEMENT AND TRIED TO CUT OFF HER HAIR, NOT KNOWING SHE WAS THE FEDERAL JUDGE ASSIGNED TO THEIR TRIAL IN TWENTY MINUTES

Chapter 16

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

That morning I was scheduled to preside over a pending criminal case on my docket, a trial already underway, and the morning's business was testimony. Two arresting officers were scheduled to appear as witnesses. I had read their reports the night before at my kitchen table, with a pen in my hand, and I had marked the places where their accounts diverged from each other and from the physical record. That is ordinary work. It is not personal work. A judge does not decide a witness's credibility before the witness takes the stand, and I had not. I had simply noted what I would need to ask, and what the parties would need to be allowed to ask, and I had closed the file.

I parked in the judicial lot on the east side, as I always did, and walked toward the public entrance because the judges' entrance was closed for maintenance that week. The notice had been posted on Friday. I did not mind the detour. The walk was short, across concrete that was still damp from the night's rain, and the air had the clean, mineral smell that follows rain in a city. I carried my briefcase in my left hand and my robe bag over my right shoulder. I was not wearing the robe. I never wore it outside the courtroom. A robe worn on the street invites a kind of attention that serves no purpose, and I preferred to arrive as a person first and put the office on only when the court was in session.

The two officers were standing near the steps. I noticed them before they spoke to me because they were not in the posture of people waiting for someone. They were in the posture of people positioned to intercept someone. One was taller, with a close haircut and a uniform that fit him tightly across the shoulders. The other was shorter and broader, and he kept his hands at his sides in a way that suggested he was conscious of keeping them there. I would later learn their names in full, from the record, but in that moment I registered only that they were police officers, that they were on duty, and that they were looking directly at me as I approached.

"Ma'am, we need you to stop right there," the taller one said. His voice was not loud. It was flat, practiced, the voice of a man who has said the same sentence many times and expects it to produce the same result.

I stopped. I did not do so out of deference. I did so because stopping costs nothing and clarifies everything. If a person with authority asks you to stop, you stop, you listen, and then you decide what the law requires next. That is what I tell law clerks. That is what I told myself.

"We need identification," the shorter one said.

I told them who I was. I said my name clearly, Naomi Ellison, and I said that I was a judge of this court, and that I was on my way inside to preside that morning. I did not raise my voice. I did not present it as a threat or as an appeal. I presented it as a fact, because it was a fact, and because facts are the only currency that matters in a proceeding. I expected a correction, an apology, a step back. People make mistakes about identity at courthouses every day. Visitors are mistaken for defendants. Defendants are mistaken for visitors. The building is full of strangers, and the first task of security is sorting.

What happened instead was a refusal to sort. The taller officer shook his head slightly, as if I had offered him a story he had already decided not to believe, and said, "We need to see an ID card, not a story." The shorter officer repeated the demand, more slowly, as if slowness would make it more lawful.

I carry a judicial identification card. Every judge does. It is a laminated card with a photograph, a name, a title, and a seal. It is not a talisman. It does not confer immunity, and I have never treated it as if it did. But it is the document the courthouse itself issues for exactly this purpose: to establish, at a glance, who a person is and what business they have in the building. I took it from the inside pocket of my briefcase and held it out. I did not hand it over. I held it where they could read it, because handing over a document to a person who has already decided you are lying is not cooperation. It is surrender of the only proof you have.

News in the same category

THEY DRAGGED A HELPLESS WOMAN INTO THE COURTHOUSE BASEMENT AND TRIED TO CUT OFF HER HAIR, NOT KNOWING SHE WAS THE FEDERAL JUDGE ASSIGNED TO THEIR TRIAL IN TWENTY MINUTES

45 Part