THEY DRAGGED A HELPLESS WOMAN INTO THE COURTHOUSE BASEMENT AND TRIED TO CUT OFF HER HAIR, NOT KNOWING SHE WAS THE FEDERAL JUDGE ASSIGNED TO THEIR TRIAL IN TWENTY MINUTES

Chapter 21

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

I know now, from the record that was assembled afterward, that the taller officer was Derek Voss and the shorter officer was Shane Pruitt, and that both men were scheduled to appear that morning as the arresting officers set to testify in the pending criminal case on my docket. I did not know their names in the room. I knew only their faces, their voices, and their hands. But the fact that they were the witnesses for that morning matters, and it mattered even before I knew their names, because it changed the character of what was happening. This was not a random encounter between a citizen and two strangers in uniform. This was an encounter between a presiding judge and the very officers whose testimony she was scheduled to hear, in a case where their credibility would be tested by examination, by cross-examination, and by the documents they had themselves prepared. A witness who detains his judge before testifying has not merely committed a wrong against a person. He has interfered with the proceeding itself. He has tried to reorder the relationship between the bench and the witness stand, to make the judge answerable to the witness before the witness answers to the court. I understood that inversion in the room, even without names to attach to it, and I held onto it because it gave the events a legal shape that the humiliation alone did not have. Humiliation is personal. Interference with a proceeding is institutional. Both were present, but only the second could be addressed by an order, and I am, before anything else, a person who writes orders.

I thought, while I stood there, about the courtroom upstairs, which I could picture with a precision that surprised me. I could picture the bench, dark wood, worn at the edges where generations of judges have rested their hands. I could picture the witness stand to my right, the jury box to my left, empty that morning because the jury had not yet been brought in, and the counsel tables with their files stacked in the order each lawyer preferred. I could picture my law clerk, who would have arrived by then and placed the morning's motions on the bench in the order I had requested, and the courtroom deputy, who would have checked the microphones and the recording system. I could picture the parties waiting, not knowing why the judge had not yet taken the bench, and the lawyers exchanging the quiet, professional glances that lawyers exchange when a proceeding is delayed for a reason no one will state. That picture steadied me. It reminded me that the courtroom was not an abstraction. It was a room with furniture and people and a schedule, and I was absent from it for a reason that had nothing to do with illness or emergency or any legitimate cause. My absence would itself become a fact in the case, and I did not want that fact to be vague. I wanted it to be exact: detained, in the lower-level service corridor of the east wing, by the arresting officers scheduled to testify, at a time when I was expected to preside.

I also thought about the fourteen months that had brought me to that bench, not in any sentimental way, but as a matter of record. Fourteen months is not a long tenure. It is long enough to learn the building, to learn the clerks by name, to learn which courtroom deputies run a tight docket and which ones let a hearing drift. It is not long enough to become complacent, and I had not become complacent. I still prepared the night before. I still read the reports with a pen in my hand. I still arrived early, because early arrival is a form of respect for the people who must wait for you. I had not sought the bench in order to be deferred to on a sidewalk. I had sought it, insofar as anyone seeks such a thing, in order to do the work carefully, in public, under rules that apply to everyone in the room, including the judge. That is why the stop outside had offended me on a level deeper than personal affront. It was not merely that two officers had refused to believe who I was. It was that they had refused the method by which identity is established in a courthouse: by document, by verification, by reference to a record that can be checked. They had replaced verification with assertion, and assertion with force, and force with a closed door. Each step was a departure from procedure, and procedure, as I have said, is what holds when people do not.

The corridor outside the room was quiet during those minutes, or quiet enough that I could hear the building itself: the hum of the fluorescent lights, the distant sound of a cart being pushed, the faint vibration of the heating system through the pipes overhead. Once, I thought I heard a telephone ring, far away and muffled, as if through a frosted-glass door. I did not attach significance to it at the time. A telephone rings in a courthouse a hundred times a day. It rings in chambers, in the clerk's office, in the records office, in the marshal's office. It is the most ordinary sound in the building, and I had no reason to single out that particular ring from any other. I note it now only because I have since learned to attend to ordinary sounds in corridors, and because a judge learns, sometimes too late, that the record is often made not by the people in the room but by the people just outside it, doing their ordinary work, unaware that their work will become evidence. I was speaking, in any case, loudly enough to be heard through a door, if a door was open, or through a wall, if a wall was thin. I continued to speak, not because I expected rescue, but because silence in that room would have been a concession, and I was not prepared to concede anything, not my name, not my office, not the fact that I was expected upstairs.

News in the same category

THEY DRAGGED A HELPLESS WOMAN INTO THE COURTHOUSE BASEMENT AND TRIED TO CUT OFF HER HAIR, NOT KNOWING SHE WAS THE FEDERAL JUDGE ASSIGNED TO THEIR TRIAL IN TWENTY MINUTES

45 Part