The taller officer took it from my hand before I could withdraw it. He looked at it for less than a second. He did not read it aloud. He did not compare the photograph to my face. He turned it between his fingers and then, with a deliberate motion that I have replayed since without finding any other word for it, he tore it. Not in half, cleanly, as paper tears. Laminate does not tear cleanly. It split and cracked, and the photograph separated from the seal, and the pieces fell to the concrete at our feet. The sound was small. It was not dramatic. It was the sound of something made to be durable being broken on purpose, and that smallness is what I remember most clearly, because it told me that this was not a misunderstanding that would resolve itself with one more sentence.
I said, "That was my identification, issued by this court." I said it because the record matters, even when there is no record yet, even when the only witnesses are the people doing the thing. I have spent fourteen months insisting that what is said in a courtroom be said clearly enough to be written down. I was not going to abandon that habit on the steps of my own courthouse.
"You can pick it up later," the shorter officer said. "Right now you're coming with us."
I asked on what authority, and for what reason, and where they intended to take me. I asked those questions in order, because order matters, and because a person who cannot answer the first question has no business proceeding to the second. They did not answer. The taller officer took my arm above the elbow. The shorter officer took the other arm. My briefcase slipped from my hand and struck the concrete. My robe bag slid from my shoulder. I did not struggle in the sense of pulling away or striking out, because struggling would have given them a narrative they did not yet have, and because I was already calculating what would happen next and what I would need to remember. But I did not walk willingly, either. I planted my feet. I said, "I do not consent to this. I am Judge Naomi Ellison, and I am expected in court this morning." I said it loudly enough that a person passing on the sidewalk turned to look, and then looked away, which is what people do when they see authority being exercised and do not want to be next.
They moved me toward the side of the building, not toward the public entrance. That choice was significant, and I understood its significance at the time, even through the shock of being handled. The public entrance has cameras, and clerks, and a line of people waiting to pass through the magnetometer. The side entrance, the service entrance on the east wing, has a door that is used for deliveries and for staff who do not want to wait in the public line. It is quieter. It is less observed. They steered me there, and the door opened from the inside with a code, and we went down.
The lower level of the east wing is not a place the public sees. It is a service corridor, long and narrow, with concrete floors and pipes running along the ceiling and doors that are marked with numbers rather than names. The light is fluorescent and unflattering. It makes everyone look tired. There is a records office down there, behind a frosted-glass door, where the clerk's office staff work among files and boxes. I knew that office existed. I had signed orders that were filed there. I did not know, in that moment, that someone was working inside it that morning, or that a telephone in that office would later become the objective record of what happened in the corridor. I knew only that the corridor smelled of cleaning solution and damp concrete, and that my shoes sounded too loud on the floor, and that the men on either side of me were no longer speaking to me at all, but to each other, in short sentences about a room at the end.
I asked again where we were going. I asked what charge, what complaint, what basis. I reminded them that officers scheduled to testify that morning were expected in my courtroom, and that interfering with a proceeding was itself a serious matter. I said these things not as threats but as statements of law, because law was the only tool I had in my hands, and because I believed, even then, that naming the law might recall them to it. The taller officer said, "You can tell it to the judge," and the shorter officer laughed, a short sound that had nothing to do with humor. That sentence stayed with me. You can tell it to the judge. I was the judge. The sentence assumed a world in which I was not, and in which the person I would tell it to was someone else, somewhere else, later. It was a sentence designed to erase the present tense.