THEY DRAGGED A HELPLESS WOMAN INTO THE COURTHOUSE BASEMENT AND TRIED TO CUT OFF HER HAIR, NOT KNOWING SHE WAS THE FEDERAL JUDGE ASSIGNED TO THEIR TRIAL IN TWENTY MINUTES

Chapter 32

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

By then, twenty minutes had not yet passed, but the clock was moving, and the morning proceeding was waiting upstairs. That proceeding was not an abstraction. It was a trial on my docket, a pending criminal case in which Officers Derek Voss and Shane Pruitt had been scheduled to appear that morning as arresting officers set to testify. I had read the witness list the night before. I knew their names on paper before I knew them in the corridor. That fact, more than any other, shaped everything I did next, because a judge who has just been involved in an incident with scheduled witnesses cannot simply walk into court and proceed as if the incident were a private matter. The case had its own integrity, separate from mine, and the defendants, the government, the jury if one had been empaneled for that phase, and the public all had an interest in a proceeding that could be trusted after that morning.

I went upstairs to chambers, changed into my robe, and reviewed the file for no more than a few minutes, not to rehearse testimony but to confirm the procedural posture: what was scheduled, what motions were pending, what testimony had already been taken, and what could be deferred without prejudice. I did not call the parties into chambers for an off-record discussion. Anything I had to say about the morning needed to be said on the record, where it could be transcribed, reviewed, and challenged if necessary. I asked my courtroom deputy to bring the courtroom to order at the scheduled time, and I took the bench on time. Punctuality, in that moment, was not a small virtue. A delayed proceeding invites speculation. A proceeding that begins on time, handled openly, tells everyone present that the court is still functioning under its rules.

When I called the case, I did so in the ordinary form, with the case name and number, and I noted for the record the appearances of counsel. Then I paused, because the next words would define whether the proceeding survived the morning intact. I spoke slowly, and I kept my language to facts and procedure, not to character or motive, because a judge's feelings about an incident are not evidence and have no place in an order.

I stated on the record that, earlier that morning, an incident had occurred in the lower level of the courthouse involving myself and Officers Voss and Pruitt, that the matter had been referred to the United States Marshals Service and to the appropriate oversight authorities, and that the officers had been separated and the relevant recordings and equipment preserved. I did not describe the incident in graphic detail. I did not characterize the officers' intent. I did not ask the courtroom to draw conclusions about the pending case from an incident that was not part of that case's evidence. I said only what was necessary for the parties to understand why the schedule for the day would change, and why the court was taking the steps it was about to take.

Then I stated my handling, clearly and in a single consistent course, so that no party would later have to guess at it. The testimony of Officers Voss and Pruitt would not proceed that day. It was continued. I continued it not as a sanction and not as a finding, but because a witness who is the subject of a pending investigation arising from an incident involving the presiding judge cannot testify before that judge that same morning without creating an appearance problem that no instruction can cure. The jury, if it heard them, would be asked to weigh credibility while knowing, or sensing, that something unresolved stood between the bench and the stand. Counsel would be placed in an impossible position, forced either to exploit the incident or to ignore it. The record would be tainted not by what the officers said, but by the circumstances under which they said it. A continuance avoided all of that without deciding anything about the merits of the investigation or about the underlying case.

I was careful to define the scope of that continuance. It applied to the officers' testimony only. It did not dismiss the case. It did not strike prior testimony. It did not exclude evidence that had been properly admitted through other witnesses. It did not decide whether the officers would testify at a later date, before me or before another judge, or whether their testimony would be handled by stipulation, by deposition, or by other means consistent with the rules. Those questions would be addressed after the investigation had developed, with briefing from the parties, and with full opportunity to be heard. For that morning, the continuance was a pause, not a conclusion, and I said so explicitly, so that neither side could later claim that I had used the incident to shape the trial's outcome.

News in the same category

THEY DRAGGED A HELPLESS WOMAN INTO THE COURTHOUSE BASEMENT AND TRIED TO CUT OFF HER HAIR, NOT KNOWING SHE WAS THE FEDERAL JUDGE ASSIGNED TO THEIR TRIAL IN TWENTY MINUTES

45 Part