words about it. So Jesse walked the camp in the long afternoon light, and the
camp let him, with that same deliberate inattention, and what he saw took its
place in him alongside the ashes he had walked at the gathering ground, fact
against fact.
He saw the winter stores — and saw how little there was to see. A people
wintering in their own ground should have been rich that autumn: meal in the
baskets, meat on the racks, the caches along the trails full against the cold.
What the racks held would not have fed this camp through the first month of
snow. Women were grinding with the unhurried steadiness of people who
know that the stones must not be hurried because there is not enough grain to
waste a motion on. In the shade of a wickiup an old woman sat shelling the
last of a basket of beans into a bowl, counting them the way a banker counts,
and beside her a girl of ten was learning the count, and neither of them
looked up.
He saw the cache pit the young men were digging at the bowl's edge, in the
old way, stone-lined and hidden under a fall of rock, and he understood
without being told that it would be dug and left conspicuously unfinished —
because a cache is only a secret while no stranger has watched its digging,
and the caches that mattered, the ones along the trails north and east, were
the ones Nascha carried in her memory, and this pit was a thing the camp
could afford to let him see.
And he saw Kito watching him see it, and read the boy's face as plainly as
track: you are counting us, scout, the way your kind counts — mouths, rifles,
stores — and the count you carry back will be the size of the column they
send. Jesse stopped beside the drying racks and took out the slate and wrote,
and held it so the boy had to read it:
43
I AM NOT COUNTING. I AM WITNESSING. THERE IS A
DIFFERENCE, AND YOUR UNCLE KNOWS IT, AND ONE DAY YOU
WILL.
Kito read it and his jaw worked, and for a moment the contempt stood aside
and something younger and more uncertain showed through, a boy of
seventeen discovering that the enemy of his family's winter had come into
camp carrying nothing but a slate and was using it to defend himself badly,
in writing, like a man doing sums in a language that hurt him. "You write
like a clerk," the boy said at last. "The soldiers wrote everything too. The
burning, afterward, they wrote that as well. A clerk at the fort made a fair
copy." He turned away toward the cottonwoods. "Paper is the only trail your
people never lose."
The truth of the raid came out of Dasan the way water comes out of rock in
that country — not in a flood, in a seep, steady and without display.
"You have walked the place," the chief said. "Nascha writes me that you
walked it with your own feet and read it with your own eyes, and that you are
a man who believes the ground over the tongue. So. I will tell you what the
ground was, before it was a camp in your people's telling."
It had been a gathering camp, he said. Not a village and not a war camp — a
working camp, set where the mesquite stood thickest along the creek bottom,
because the beans were ripe and the grinding could not wait for safer weather
in safer country. Women, mostly. Old people. Children. A screen of young
men no thicker than the one around this bowl, and they had been two days
gone to the river crossings when the riders came at dawn. The camp's wealth
had been exactly what Jesse had read in the ashes: mesquite meal in woven
baskets, dried meat, winter stores laid by against the cold — the whole
margin between this band and starvation, gathered bean by bean through a
44
summer's labor.
"The white telling says stolen cattle were recovered there," Dasan said. "You
walked it. You found no cattle."
Jesse shook his head, once.
"You found our horses' corral, and the ash of our food, and a child's shoe."
The chief's voice did not rise. "The horses were nine. Old mares and a
gelding with a split hoof among them, for the children to ride and the old
ones to be lifted onto. In the white telling they have become cattle, and
recovered, and driven off in triumph. I am an old man and I have heard many
white tellings, and I will tell you the thing they all have in common, scout.
They are told by the men who did the burning, about the people who were
burned, to other men who were not there. And the burning was the purpose.
Not the camp. The stores. They poured your people's coal oil on the meal and
the meat — Nascha smelled it on the wind before she saw the smoke, she has
told me this — so that we must make a choice your Mr. Krell has prepared
for us like a corral with one gate. Starve in the hills, where there is nothing
left to gather. Or come down to the mesa and be counted, and be removed to
the place the paper has chosen for us, where the copper is not."
He let the silence stand a moment.
"And my niece," he said. "You will have wondered why her taking was