it and let it play — and set the slate down on the schoolhouse floor beside the
chair, flat, face up, blank. And sat down in the chair without it.
He took the oath with his name spoken aloud, and the speaking of it told him
the rate for the rest of the day. Delaney leaned forward. "Mr. Malone, the
court knows your circumstances. If at any point you require to rest, or to
95
write, you have only to say so." — "I'll do it the once, Your Honor. Aloud."
— "Then tell the court what you saw, in your own time, when you rode into
the valley of the two creeks on the morning following the events the elder
has described."
So he told it — slowly, because slowly was the only speed he had, and
because slowness is not weakness if a man fills it with fact. He had ridden in
at first light, having ridden all night on a runner's word, and the valley had
smelled before he saw it: kerosene, lying over the cold air like a hand over a
mouth, an oil smell in a place where no lamp had ever been lit in anger. He
had walked the camp as he was taught to walk ground in the Army: in a
spiral, from the outside in, reading the rings.
The outer ring: horse sign in plenty, all of it shod — iron on every track off
the ridge and iron on every track back up it. A war party, he said, does not
shoe its horses at the agency blacksmith and ride them in a circle like a plow
team. The second ring: the shelters, undisturbed. Nothing taken — not a
blanket, not a kettle, not a hide. A raid takes; that is the definition of the
thing. Whatever rides off with nothing was not there to steal.
The third ring was the center, and the metates. He had wondered all night
whether to include them — they were not evidence as a court counts
evidence, and he feared they would sound like his feelings dressed as
testimony. But they had been there, and his promise was to the thing itself.
The grinding stones, four of them, in their row by the ramada. Turned over
— not smashed; turned over, each one, face down in the ash, by men
working methodically, because a metate face down in the dirt is a woman's
whole labor cancelled, and somebody in that line of riders had known it.
"They knew what they were burning," he said. "It wasn't a mistake of the
dark. It was informed." His jaw was a coal by then, and he drank from the
96
glass the clerk set at his elbow, and the whole room waited with him — and
he understood that the waiting was a thing the slate could never have bought
him: the whole valley leaning toward his broken voice, because he would not
write it down and pass it around like a bill of sale.
The last of it was the absence, and he had saved it for last, the way you save
the center of a spiral for the feet that have done the walking. "There were no
cattle. I want to be exact about it, because exact is all I'm good for. There
was no sign of cattle in the camp or out of it. No herd had been held there, or
driven through there, or been near that valley in those days — and I read that
ground the way I read it for the Army for money, and I stake my name on it,
which is the only stake I've got left that's worth anything. There was no
remuda. No warriors' lodges, no horse herd, no war camp. There was a
child's shoe by the fire ring, a little shoe, burned on the one side. There were
the metates, face down. There was the oil, poured sack by sack by men who
took their time. It was a kitchen, gentlemen. Somebody burned a kitchen, and
took the woman who kept it, and wrote the word cattle over the whole of it
afterward, in a fair hand, in a ledger. I have seen the ledger. I have seen the
kitchen. They are not the same country."
Hollis rose with the file's edge showing, and went where Jesse had known he
would go. First the wound, politely: would Mr. Malone agree that pain, over
years, could make a man fierce in his opinions. "It has made me careful in
them," Jesse said. "A man who pays for words doesn't spend them on
weather." Then the ranch: Mr. Malone employed Apache labor, had for
years. "I employ men who work. I pay them in coin, which in my experience
settles the question of their tribe better than it settles the question of yours."
A sound went through the benches, quickly swallowed; Delaney did not
gavel it. And at last Hollis went to the place the whole valley had come to
97
hear asked aloud. "Mr. Malone. You shelter this woman. She has been
observed at your ranch — at your table — under your protection, against a
lawful warrant, for the better part of a month. You speak her language. You
have gone a considerable distance out of the way of your own people for her.
Will you tell the court why a white man does that?"
It was the question meant to shame him, and Jesse felt the whole long
morning gather behind the words he was about to buy at the day's highest
price, and found he was not afraid of the price anymore — only tired of the