slate. He looked at the back wall. He looked at Kito by the door. He looked
at the chair by the stove, and did not let his eyes stay there, because the
answer was not for her, and a promise cuts whichever direction it is pointed.
"I was a scout," he said, each word placed like a stone in a crossing. "Ten
years. I know what a camp looks like. I know what a lie looks like. They are
different things. As to the rest of it — a man shelters what comes to his door
hurt. If the court wants a shorter word for that than the ones I've got, the
court can write it down itself. I've set my slate down. I'm done writing."
He sat back with his face wet and his hands open on his knees, and the pain
collected its due all at once behind his eyes, and the schoolhouse swam. Then
Corbett's hand was on the back of the chair — not touching him, just there,
as it had been all day — and Delaney's voice came through the ache like a
man speaking across a river. "The court thanks you, Mr. Malone. Sit a
moment. Clerk, bring the witness water. The court will recess for one hour.
When we return, the court will take up a document presently under seal."
When the court came back, the light came in low and red through the west
windows, and the riders' line along the back wall had lost some of its polish;
there were gaps in it, and Dobie stood at the end with his hat in both hands
now, like a mourner who has begun to suspect whose funeral it is.
98
Delaney took up the brown paper packet and broke its three seals with his
thumbnail, in full view of the room, and drew out a copybook bound in black
oilcloth, and held it up. "This is a memorandum book, kept by Mr. Walter
Pye, bookkeeper to Krell Consolidated — a private record of counts, gathers,
and remittances, not maintained at his employer's instruction. A copy, in Mr.
Pye's own hand, was lodged under seal with this court's clerk six weeks ago,
by Mr. Pye himself, through an intermediary, at some personal risk. Mr. Pye
will come forward."
Walter Pye came down the aisle — twenty-three, with a clerk's stoop already
forming and ink on his fingers to match the schoolmaster's, and a face that
had rehearsed this walk on so many sleepless nights that the real one held an
air of mercy: it was only as bad as he had feared, and not worse. He took the
oath in a voice that barely reached the clerk. Delaney turned the copybook to
a marked page. "Is that your hand, Mr. Pye?" — "It is, Your Honor." —
"Read the entry. Aloud. Slowly."
Pye read it. It was bookkeeping, nothing but bookkeeping, and that was its
whole horror: the ledger with no fair hand over it. The count at the fall
gather: complete. The remuda: complete. The herd driven out and driven
back: complete. The variance for the season, from all causes — death,
straying, two steers to a lion on the mesa in August — eleven head. Eleven,
against two hundred in the sworn complaint. "And this entry," Delaney said.
"In the margin, dated the following week. Read that too." Pye's voice, Jesse
noticed, improved as he went; each sentence stood a little straighter than the
one before, like a line of men finding their dressing. "Asked Mr. D. about the
gather count for the complaint. Mr. D. states the count was taken at the home
ranch in my absence and I am to copy the figures as given. No gather ridden
on the north range this season. Figures for the affidavit not mine. Have
99
copied them as ordered. The herd has never varied."
"Mr. Pye," Delaney said, gently, as a man handles a loaded thing, "explain
that entry in plain words, without bookkeeping."
"It means the complaint was written from a muster that did not happen, Your
Honor. There was no gather on the north range at all — I kept the remittance
book; I'd have paid the riders for it. The herd's true count never varied
beyond what weather and lions account for. I was ordered to copy figures for
the affidavit, and I copied them. Which is why I made the copy. A man ought
to have one true set of books. Even if it's the one that hangs him."
Hollis did not rise — the first time all day Jesse had seen a man choose, in
public and at full price, not to do the thing he was paid for. Krell sat with his
hands folded exactly as at ten o'clock, looking like a man watching a river
take a bridge he had been assured was sound.
Delaney put his hands flat on the teacher's desk and gave the ruling whole, in
the late light, in a voice that never rose and never needed to, while the clerk's
pen went after it like a dog after a wagon. The warrant was quashed, for want
of a crime to stand it on. The court found that no cattle had been stolen at the
time alleged or any time material to the complaint; that no raid had occurred;
that the gathering camp had been a camp of women and children and old
men, whose winter stores had been burned by persons riding the company's
horses — a matter referred, with the whole of this record, to the territorial
prosecutor. The woman Nascha was declared a free woman: no man's