It's quite all right, Agnes, Dean Whitfield said from the doorway of her office. She had come out at the sound, and she stood very still, her hands at her sides, her face calm. "Mrs. Ashford. Come in."
Mrs. Ashford swept past Mrs. Porter without a glance and into the Dean's office, where she removed her gloves slowly, finger by finger, and sat down in the chair opposite the desk without being asked. Dean Whitfield closed the door, quietly, and took her own seat. She did not offer tea. She did not offer small talk. She folded her hands on the blotter and waited.
I will come directly to the point, Eleanor, Mrs. Ashford said. "I am concerned about the direction of this year's scholarship competition. Deeply concerned."
I am listening, Dean Whitfield said.
Mrs. Ashford leaned forward slightly. "A girl with no training, no teacher, and no background has been advanced to the final round. She plays charmingly, I am told. She has a touching story. But the Harrison Academy is not a charity, and the Founders' Scholarship is not a prize for the most touching story. It is for the finest young pianist in the country. My daughter is that pianist. Everyone in this building knows it. And yet I am told that the judges are — divided."
The judges are doing their work, Dean Whitfield said evenly. "They listen. They deliberate. They decide on the playing, and on nothing else. That is the process, and it has been the process for fifty years."
Process, Mrs. Ashford repeated, as if the word tasted unpleasant. "Eleanor, let us speak plainly, as friends. My family has given a great deal to this Academy. The Ashford wing. The scholarship fund. The new roof on the Recital Hall. We have given because we believe in excellence, and because we believe this institution stands for something. If the scholarship goes to a girl who has never had a lesson, what does that say about excellence? What does it say to every family that has invested in their child's training?"
It says, Dean Whitfield said, "that excellence can come from more than one place. And that this Academy is willing to recognize it wherever it finds it."
Mrs. Ashford's eyes narrowed. "I am not sure you understand me. I am saying that if Maya Chen advances further — if she wins — I will have to reconsider my family's support. The board will hear from me. The other donors will hear from me. I do not make threats, Eleanor. I make decisions. And I am very close to making one."
The office was very quiet. Outside the window, the light was thin and gray, and a few flakes of snow had begun to fall, drifting past the glass like ash. Dean Whitfield looked at Mrs. Ashford for a long moment, and her face did not change, and her hands did not move, and when she spoke, her voice was as calm as it had been from the beginning, and colder, somehow, for its calmness.
Celeste, she said, "I have known you for twenty years. I have sat beside you at board meetings, and at concerts, and at dinners where we both smiled until our faces hurt. And I have always respected you, even when we disagreed. So I am going to speak to you as plainly as you have spoken to me."
She stood up, and walked to the window, and looked out at the falling snow.
This Academy was founded by people who believed that music belongs to anyone with the discipline to learn it and the courage to play it. Not to the wealthy. Not to the well-connected. To anyone. The Founders' Scholarship is awarded by judges, on the basis of playing, in a hall, in front of witnesses. It is not awarded by donors. It is not awarded by boards. It is not awarded by me. If you withdraw your funding because you do not like the outcome of a fair process, that will be your decision, and you will have to live with what it says about you. But you will not buy this decision. Not while I am Dean.
Mrs. Ashford rose slowly from her chair. Her face was very pale, and for a moment Dean Whitfield thought she might shout. Instead, Mrs. Ashford picked up her gloves, and put them on, one finger at a time, with great care, and when she spoke again, her voice was controlled, and a little thinner than before.
You are making a mistake, Eleanor.
Perhaps, Dean Whitfield said. "But it will be an honest mistake, made for the right reason. I can live with that."
Mrs. Ashford left without another word. The door closed behind her with a soft, final sound, and Dean Whitfield stood at the window for a long time, watching the snow fall, feeling the weight of what she had just done settle onto her shoulders. She had known, when she took this job, that there would be a day when principle cost something. She had not known it would cost this much, or that it would come in the shape of a woman she had once called a friend.
Mrs. Porter came in quietly, with a cup of tea, and set it on the desk without being asked.
Are you all right, Dean? she asked.
I am, Dean Whitfield said, and she turned from the window, and picked up the tea, and held it in both hands, feeling the warmth come back into her fingers. "Thank you, Agnes. And Agnes — please make sure Miss Chen knows nothing of this conversation. She is to prepare for her final in peace. Whatever happens on Monday, she will know it was decided by her playing, and by nothing else. That is the least we owe her."