Told to Keep It Simple, She Turned the Piano into Pure Magic Before Their Eyes...

Chapter 35

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Bennett listened. He had expected this argument, and he had rehearsed an answer all week — but in the community center hallway, and again in the hall this morning, the answer had changed. He sat with his hands folded, and he thought about the Nocturne, and he thought about the four notes, and he thought about the silence after the last note, the silence that had lasted a beat longer than applause, and he thought about Pittsburgh, and the teacher who had told him to stop showing off, and he thought about the girl in the plain room with the old piano, playing the same phrase over and over until it was true.

The story is not the playing, Bennett said, and his voice was measured, the way it always was, but there was something underneath it that the other judges had not heard before, something that made them all look at him. "I want to be very clear about that, because it is the objection I have carried around all week, and it is a fair objection, and it deserves an answer. We are not here to reward a story. We are here to reward playing. So let us talk about the playing."

He looked down at his judging sheet, and he spoke the way he had spoken to a thousand students: clearly, without excess, each word in its place.

Miss Ashford played a difficult piece flawlessly, and with feeling, and it was a performance any school in the country would be proud of. I have written that down. I mean it. But Miss Chen played a piece that is, on the surface, simpler, and she played it with a command of tone, of line, of breath, that I have heard from very few pianists at any age. Her phrasing was not an accident. Her dynamics were not luck. The way she voiced the melody against the accompaniment, the way she let the music breathe, the way she held the silence at the end — those are not the marks of a lucky amateur. Those are the marks of a musician. A musician who has listened, deeply, for a very long time, and who has learned to play what she hears.

He paused. The room was very quiet. The wind moved the maple branches outside the window.

I told her, in the first round, to keep it simple, Bennett said. "I meant it as a correction. I meant: do not reach beyond yourself. Do not show off. Play what you can play. And she heard me, and she did something I did not expect. She did not play less. She played more truly. She took the simplest thing in the world — a melody, a few notes, a lullaby her father used to hum — and she put nothing between herself and the music. Nothing extra. Nothing to hide behind. That is not simplicity as I taught it. That is simplicity as it ought to be taught. And I am telling you, as the chair of this department, that I heard it, and that I will not pretend I did not."

Okafor was nodding, slowly, and the woman with the silver glasses had taken her glasses off and was wiping them, and the man with the beard was looking down at his own sheet, where he had written, in the margin, a single word: magic. He had not meant to write it. He had written it anyway.

There is also the matter of the motif, Bennett went on. "The four notes she wove into the Nocturne. Some of you may call that an addition, a liberty. I call it musicianship. She did not decorate the piece. She completed it, in the only way it could be completed by her. The piece was Chopin's. The performance was hers. And the performance was, in every particular that matters, superb."

Dean Whitfield spoke then, quietly, from the far end of the table. "Professor Bennett, are you saying that your recommendation is for the Founders' Scholarship to go to Miss Chen?"

I am, Bennett said. "On musical grounds. On the playing alone. I am saying that the finest playing I heard today, the playing that showed the deepest understanding of music, was Maya Chen's. And I am saying it knowing full well what it costs me to say it, because it means that something I have believed for forty years was incomplete. I would rather be corrected by the truth than be right on a technicality."

Silence. The coffee went cold. Then Okafor said, "I second that," and the woman with the silver glasses said, "I agree," and the man with the beard said, slowly, "So do I," and one by one the judges nodded, and wrote it down, and the decision was made fairly, on the playing, with every sheet accounted for.

Bennett sat back in his chair, and he felt something in his chest that he had not felt in a very long time, something like relief, and something like the beginning of a long road back to the thing he had first loved. He thought about the girl in the green room, waiting, not knowing, and he thought about the community center hallway, and the sound of the piano through the door, and he thought, She kept it simple. And it was true.

The Recital Hall was full again, and the air was warm with bodies and breath and the low murmur of three hundred people waiting. Maya sat in the green room with Victoria, and neither of them spoke, and the silence between them was not awkward. It was the silence of two people who have both done their best and are waiting to hear what the world will say about it. Victoria's hands were folded in her lap, perfectly still. Maya's hands were folded too, and they were shaking, just a little, and she did not try to stop them.

News in the same category

Told to Keep It Simple, She Turned the Piano into Pure Magic Before Their Eyes...

45 Part