"Was it?"
"Well, we've found a good reason."
"That's different from finding her reason."
Inez looked annoyed for precisely as long as it took her to understand that he was right. "You're getting to be a damned nuisance, Avery."
"It's a gift."
They played the last inch of tape, after Mae had put the phone down. Ruth's voice said something that sounded like green cupboard. Then a click. So quiet it was almost covered by the motor, a child's voice asked a question. They could not make it out. By the date of the recording Mae's eldest would have been scarcely two.
Inez wrote a second triangle on a clean white label and set it beside the first. "I hate mysteries," she said. "They leave you with half a sandwich on the table for six hours."
It was only when he got home that Leo realized why the date was wrong. The old mixer had broken down before Cal was born. The recording of Mae's call had been added to a reel of older sounds, and Ruth, who labeled everything down to her last broken pencil, had been the one to put it there.
Half a Pair of Scissors
On Thursday Nell's class went to the school hall to make costumes for the summer parade. At each end of a table lay a pair of scissors attached to a length of orange string, an arrangement intended to prevent loss but admirably suited to producing knots. The children had been invited to design costumes representing the work they hoped to do when they grew up. Most of the boys had volunteered to be people who sat in spacecraft. Two girls proposed to be sharks. Miss Amos said she would look into what qualifications this required.
Nell wanted to be an architect and a person who carried out explosions in an orderly fashion. She hoped these jobs could be combined. She made a cardboard helmet, a folding ruler, and a paper belt with loops for carrying string. Kit, who planned to be a word collector, was trying to decide whether his collection ought to be worn in alphabetical order.
Near the end of the lesson another child picked up a pair of scissors to trim a corner of Nell's helmet while it was still on her head. He was trying to be helpful. He was six. When she pulled away, the chair scraped loudly and a whole pot of pencils went onto the floor.
She found herself under the table with the folds of the green tablecloth against her nose. She could smell somebody's marmalade sandwich. Above her head feet moved in various directions. A small cold star on the floor turned out to be a silver sequin. She picked it up and closed her fist on it.
"Would you like a person under here?" Miss Amos asked from the opening in the cloth.
"Just me for a minute."
"Okay. I'm putting the pencils back. There are forty of the things so it'll take as long as you need."
Nell considered crawling all the way down and coming out through a different door and going to live in the lighthouse. But she didn't know anybody there, the brother who disliked gulls was dead, and there would be a lot of steps if you wanted a biscuit.
"Is Albie in trouble?"
"He put the scissors down when you moved. I'll explain about asking. He isn't in trouble."
"Am I?"
"No. There's a bit of a bump on two of the pencils but I expect they'll live."
Nell came out. Everybody was making things. Albie was cutting silver foil into flames for his rocket propulsion pack. She placed the sequin on the tongue of her helmet, right where an architect of the highest rank would logically wear a star.
At pickup she had two versions of the afternoon to choose between. In one a boy with scissors had made her hide under a table. In the other she had gone under a table and come out again under her own power. Both were true. She gave her father both. Then she asked if they could get an ice cream with the dangerous red syrup that stained you even if you only happened to walk past it.
On the bench by the ferry Leo said, "Would you like me to speak to Albie's parents?"