problem. The problem was that kindness wanted something back — a story, a visit, a seat at a table — and Frankie had spent five years learning how to need nothing from anybody, because needing things was how you ended up watching them leave.
Daniel and their little girl, Maeve, had died of fever in the summer of 1876, six weeks apart, and Frankie had buried them herself on the rise behind the house, because the nearest neighbor was four miles off and the ground was soft from rain and there was no one else to do it. She went up to the rise every Sunday evening, when the light went gold over the grass, and she sat between the two stones and told them the week's news: who had stopped, what the creek was doing, whether the beans had come up. She did not cry there anymore. The crying had finished itself in the first year, the way a fire finishes itself when there is nothing left to burn. What remained was a quieter thing, a kind of steady attention, as if by keeping the graves tidy and the stones upright she were keeping a promise she had made without words. Daniel had built the back room with his own hands. Maeve had loved to stand on the porch and watch storms come in. Frankie kept the house the way they had left it, not out of superstition but out of respect: the room was theirs, and she was only its keeper now.
The nightmares came anyway. Not every night, but often enough that she kept a lamp lit by the bed and a book open face-down on the pillow, so that waking had somewhere to go. In the dream she was always back at the cholera post, in the summer when the river ran low and the tents filled faster than the orderlies could dig. She was the only nurse on the women's ward, and the surgeon had sent her three miles to the depot for medicine, because the post had run out and the next shipment was a week away. She had gone. Of course she had gone. A nurse does not refuse an order to fetch medicine. But the road was washed out and the depot clerk was drunk and the medicine was locked in a shed whose key nobody could find, and by the time she got back, with the bottles rattling in her satchel, three women on her ward were dead who had been alive when she left. Not the sickest three. Just the three whose turn it was while she was gone. In the dream, she always walked back into the tent and found their cots empty and their blankets folded, and the surgeon looked at her and said nothing at all, which was worse than anything he could have said. She woke from it with her heart hammering and her hands already reaching for a lamp, as if light itself were a kind of medicine.
She never told anyone about the dream. She never told anyone about the cholera post at all. What she told people, when they asked why a woman kept a waystation alone, was that the work suited her, which was true enough to pass. The fuller truth was that she had once left her post, for good reason and with good intentions, and people had died while she was gone, and she had decided, quietly and without ceremony, that she would never leave a post again. She would stay. She would be the person who stayed. It was not a vow she had spoken aloud. It was simply the shape her life had taken, the way a river takes the shape of the ground it runs over, without asking permission. And it worked, mostly. The ledger stayed open. The bread got baked. The guests came and went. The graves stayed tidy. The only thing the shape could not hold was the dream, which came back whenever it pleased, like a guest who never paid and never left.
The summer of 1881 was dry. Everyone said so, the way people say things that are true and useless at the same time. The creek ran low. The grass cured early and stood pale and brittle on the flats, and the wind came off the west with a sound like paper tearing. Frankie watched the sky the way farmers watch it, which is to say, constantly and without hope. She kept the barrels full. She kept the