"I know it is not true," Abel said at last. "I know Tomas Herrera has lived on that ground since before I came to this valley, and I know his father is buried on it, and his wife is buried on it, and his son would be buried on it if the mine company had let them bring the body home. I know all of that, Frankie. What I want to know is what you want me to do about it."
Frankie took the petition out of her coat and unfolded it on the bench beside the harness. The paper shook a little in her hands, and she hated that it shook, because she was not a woman whose hands shook. But Abel did not seem to notice, or if he noticed, he was too decent to say so.
"I want you to sign it," she said. "It says they never left. It says they live there now. That is all it says. If enough of us sign it, Larkin cannot stand in front of the county and say the valley agrees the land is empty, because the valley will have said otherwise, in its own hand."
Abel read the paper slowly, moving his lips a little as he read, the way men do who learned their letters late and are not ashamed of it. Then he took the pencil Frankie offered him and signed his name in large, careful letters at the top of the page, Abel Ferreira, with a firm underline beneath it, as if he were signing a deed rather than a petition.
"There," he said, and handed the pencil back. "I am first, then. That is fitting. I have been first to take Tomas's corn and first to borrow his mules when my own went lame, and I will be first to say he never left, because he never did."
Frankie folded the paper again, and her throat was tight in a way she did not expect. She had thought that asking would feel like begging. It did not. It felt like setting down a weight she had not known she was carrying, and finding that someone else was willing to pick up one end of it.
"Thank you, Abel," she said.
"Do not thank me," Abel said, and picked up his harness again. "Go and get the rest of them. Hannah Weiss will sign, and so will the Donnellys, and so will the Fletchers, if you ask them plain and do not dress it up. People here do not like to be dressed up. They like to be asked plain."
Frankie walked back down the lane with the paper warm against her ribs, and she thought about what Abel had said, and about how strange it was that the hardest part had not been the asking at all. The hardest part had been the walking there. Once she had stood in the yard and said the true thing out loud, the rest had come the way water comes when you finally clear a blocked spring: not all at once, but steady, and with a sound she had almost forgotten.
The road to Hannah Weiss's store was longer, and it took her past the creek where the willows were coming into leaf. Hannah was behind her counter counting bolts of cloth when Frankie came in, and the bell over the door rang the way it rang at the waystation, a small, familiar sound that made Frankie think of her own door and how many strangers had come through it and how few neighbors had.
"Frankie O'Rourke," Hannah said, and her spectacles caught the light. "You are out early, and you are not carrying a basket, so you have not come to buy. What have you come for?"
Frankie laid the petition on the counter and smoothed it flat with her palm. Hannah read it, and as she read, her face changed in the way that faces change when someone hears a thing they already believed but have never been asked to say.
"Abel signed first," Frankie said, and pointed to the name at the top of the page. "I am asking everyone in the valley. Not for money. Not for a fight. Just for their names, saying what is true."
Hannah took the pencil and signed beneath Abel's name, Hannah Weiss, in a neat, upright hand, and then she did something Frankie had not expected: she reached across the counter and took Frankie's hand in both of hers, and held it there for a moment, hard.