Clara nodded, and she took Ethan's hand, and she looked at her daughters, asleep at the end of the bed, their heads together, their hair tangled, their hands almost touching, and she thought about the year she had lost, and the years she had ahead of her, and she thought, for the first time in a long time, that the years ahead might be enough.
Dr. Samuel Ortiz was seventy-four years old, and he lived in a retirement home by the sea, and he had not practiced medicine in six years, and he had not slept well in six years either, because there are some things a man cannot forget, no matter how much money he is paid to forget them.
Detective Kim and Ethan went to see him on a Tuesday morning, and they sat in the garden of the retirement home, under a tree, and Detective Kim put a recorder on the table, and she said, "Dr. Ortiz, we need to talk about the night of October seventeenth, six years ago, at Mercy General Hospital. We need to talk about the Marsh twins."
Dr. Ortiz was quiet for a long time. He looked at the sea. He looked at his hands. And then he said, "I knew this day would come. I have been waiting for it for six years. I told myself I did it for the money. I told myself I did it because Henry Marsh threatened me, because he said he would ruin me, because he said my daughter would lose her scholarship. And all of that was true. But it wasn't the whole truth. The whole truth is that I did it because I was afraid, and because I was tired, and because it was easier to sign a piece of paper than to stand up to a man like Henry Marsh. And I have regretted it every day since."
He told them everything. He told them about the delivery, about the two girls, about the smaller twin, about Silas Grant standing in the doorway, about Henry Marsh's instructions, about the certificate he had forged, declaring the second baby stillborn, about the death certificate he had forged fourteen months ago, declaring Clara Marsh drowned, about the money he had been paid, about the nurse who had kept copies of the records, and who had died before she could use them.
"I have a daughter," Dr. Ortiz said, at the end, and his voice was shaking. "She's a doctor now. In Portland. She doesn't know what I did. I never told her. I was afraid she would stop loving me. But I want you to know, Mr. Marsh, that I am sorry. I am sorry for what I did to your family. I am sorry for what I did to those two little girls. And if there is anything I can do, anything at all, to make it right, I will do it."
Ethan looked at the old man, and he thought about the year Clara had spent in the dark, and the six years Ivy had spent in a cottage, believing she had no one, and he felt the anger rise in him, hot and sudden, and then he felt it go, because the old man in front of him was not Henry Marsh, and he was not Silas Grant, and he was not Meredith. He was a tired, frightened old man who had made a terrible choice, and who had lived with it for six years, and who was, at last, telling the truth.
"Tell the truth," Ethan said. "That's all. Tell the truth, and sign your name to it, and let the court decide the rest."
Dr. Ortiz signed his statement, and he asked, as Detective Kim was packing up the recorder, "Are the girls well? Are they all right?"
"They're well," Ethan said. "They're together. They're home."
Helen Brooks was eighty-one years old, and she had been a nurse at Mercy General for forty years, and she had retired six years ago, and she had spent six years waiting for someone to come and ask her what she knew, and when Detective Kim and Clara came to her door, she did not hesitate. She went to the closet, and she took down a tin box, and she set it on the table, and she opened it, and inside were the things she had kept for six years, the things she had been too afraid to use, and too guilty to throw away.