Ethan came and sat beside her on the edge of the bed, and he put his arm around her, and he said, "They're beautiful."
"They are," Clara said. "They're the most beautiful thing I have ever seen. And I almost lost them. I almost lost all of it."
"You didn't," Ethan said. "You didn't lose them. You found them. You found all of us."
Clara leaned her head against his shoulder, and she closed her eyes, and she listened to her daughters breathing, and to the house, quiet around them, and to the garden outside, growing in the dark, and she thought that this, this ordinary, quiet, lamplit room, was the most extraordinary place in the world.
They had never had a birthday together. Lily had had six birthdays, with cakes, and balloons, and friends, and presents, and Ivy had had six birthdays, alone, in a cottage, with a single candle in a cupcake, and Meredith singing, softly, a song Ivy did not know was not a birthday song at all, but a song Meredith had made up, to fill the silence.
On the seventeenth of October, six months after Clara came home, they had their first birthday together, and Clara was determined that it would be the best birthday either of them had ever had, and Ethan was determined that it would be the biggest, and Marta was determined that it would have the best cake, and Lily was determined that Ivy would blow out the candles first, because she was six minutes younger, and that meant she got to go first, and Ivy was determined that Lily would blow them out first, because she was six minutes older, and that meant she got to go first, and in the end they blew them out together, at the same time, on the count of three, and the candles went out in a single breath, and everyone cheered.
There were two cakes. One green, one blue, because green was Ivy's favorite color, and blue was Lily's, and Clara had iced them herself, and written their names on them in white icing, LILY on the blue one, IVY on the green one, and she had spelled them carefully, letter by letter, because Ivy had asked her to, because Ivy had said, very seriously, "Please spell my name right on the cake. Nobody ever spelled it right before."
There were balloons, and presents, and friends from school, and Mrs. Alvarez, and Detective Kim, who had come with a present wrapped in brown paper, and Ray, who had brought a camera, and Tomás, who had brought a bouquet of roses from the garden, and Nadia, who had brought a card she had made herself, and David Chen, who had brought a book about two sisters who lived in a house by the sea, and everyone ate cake, and drank lemonade, and played games in the garden, where the pool had been, and the sun shone, and the roses bloomed, and it was, Clara thought, the happiest day of her life.
In the evening, after the guests had gone, after the presents had been opened, after the girls were in their nightdresses, Clara sat with them in the garden, on the bench under the oak, and she told them the story of the day they were born, the real story, the whole story, about the hospital, and the two bracelets, and the blue ribbon and the green ribbon, and the nurse who had kept the photograph, and the long road that had brought them all back together, and when she had finished, Ivy was quiet for a long time, and then she said, "Mommy, were we always sisters? Even when we didn't know?"
"Yes," Clara said. "Always. From the first minute. From before the first minute. You were sisters before you were born, and you'll be sisters for the rest of your lives, no matter what happens, no matter where you go, no matter who tries to tell you otherwise."
Lily took Ivy's hand, and Ivy took Lily's hand, and they sat there, on the bench, under the oak, in the garden where the pool had been, and the sun went down, and the string lights came on, one row at a time, the way Ethan had wired them, three summers ago, when Clara was still alive to stand on the ladder and hold the drill steady and tell him he was doing it wrong, and Clara looked at the lights, and at her daughters, and at her husband, standing in the kitchen door with a cup of tea, and she thought, this is what I was knocking for. This is what I was knocking for all along.