"Thank you, David," she said. "Thank you for making it simple. I think we've all had enough of complicated."
The hearing was held on a Tuesday morning in November, in a courtroom with high windows and wooden benches, and Ethan sat between his daughters, with Clara on his other side, and Marta behind them, and Ray behind her, and the room was full of people who had come to see what would happen to the man who had buried his wife alive and the woman who had tried to steal her children.
Silas Grant sat in the defendant's chair, in a gray suit, with his lawyers, and Meredith sat beside him, in a dark dress, her hair pulled back, her face pale, and she did not look at Clara, and she did not look at Ethan, and she looked only at Ivy, once, when Ivy turned around in her seat to look at the room, and Meredith's face changed, just for a moment, into something softer, something almost like love, and then it changed back.
David Chen opened by saying that paper does not grieve, and paper does not perform, and paper does not forget, and that the papers in front of the court would tell the story, if the court would let them. And then he presented them, one by one: the shareholder agreement, the forged signatures, the bank records showing the diverted money, the locker records, the hospital records, the doctor's statement, the nurse's tin box, the bracelets, the photograph of the two babies with the blue and green ribbons.
The judge read Rose Delaney's trust, and then she read the codicil Clara had written, the codicil she had left with David Chen years ago, before she disappeared, a codicil that said, in her own handwriting, that if anything ever happened to her, her children were to be cared for by her husband, and by no one else, and that no one, not her sister, not her husband's family, not anyone, was to be named their guardian without the court's approval.
Ethan testified first, about the night of the proposal, about the knocking, about the hatch, about the room under the pool, and the court listened, and no one interrupted, and when he had finished, the judge thanked him, and said, "Mr. Marsh, I am sorry for what your family has been through. I am sorry that it took a six-year-old girl to bring it to light. But I am glad she did."
Clara testified next, about the year in the dark, about the boat, about the drugs, about the speaker on the wall, about the three weeks she had spent widening the panel, about the night Ethan found her, and her voice was steady, and her hands were steady, and when she had finished, the courtroom was silent, and the judge said, "Mrs. Marsh, you are a very brave woman. The court thanks you."
And then Helen Brooks testified, about the night the twins were born, about the chart she had marked, about the tin box she had kept for six years, and she did not ask for forgiveness, and she did not make excuses, and when she had finished, she sat down, and she wept, quietly, into a handkerchief, and Marta reached over and took her hand.
The judge ruled on a Friday morning, three days after the hearing, and the ruling was short, and clear, and final.
The original trust was restored. Both girls were named as daughters in their own right, Lily Marsh and Ivy Marsh, born on the seventeenth of October, six years ago, at Mercy General Hospital, daughters of Ethan and Clara Marsh. The amended trust, the new will, and the guardianship petitions were set aside as forgeries. The money in the trust was to be held for the girls until they were twenty-one, and to be touched by no one, for no reason, until then.
Silas Grant was remanded in custody, to face charges of kidnapping, forgery, fraud, and attempted murder. Meredith Vane was remanded in custody, to face charges of kidnapping, forgery, and fraud. Bail was refused, in part, because the court found that both defendants had the means, and the motive, and the history, to flee, and because the court had seen what they were capable of, and did not intend to give them a second chance to do it.
Outside the courtroom, in the hallway, Meredith stopped, and she turned to Clara, and she said, very quietly, so that only Clara could hear her, "Will you tell her? Will you tell Ivy that I loved her?"