They took the letters home, and Clara put them in the tin box, with the birth ledger, and the photograph, and the bracelets, and Henry's letter, and Meredith's letter, and she closed the lid, and she put the box on the shelf, and she thought about the house on the hill, and the garden gone wild, and she decided, that night, that they would fix it up, slowly, a little at a time, and that one day, when the girls were older, it would be theirs, a house with a garden, and a gate, and a history, and no secrets left in it, at all.
The third winter after Clara came home was mild, and the snow came late, and melted quickly, and the girls were nine years old, and they were tall now, and their hair was long, and they wore their ribbons, blue and green, every day, and they went to school, and they came home, and they did their homework at the kitchen table, and they fought, sometimes, the way sisters fight, about whose turn it was to wash the dishes, and whose drawing was better, and who got the last piece of cake, and Clara would listen to them fight, and she would smile, because fighting, ordinary, sisterly fighting, was the most wonderful sound in the world, after six years of silence, after a year in the dark, after everything.
On a Saturday morning in February, the girls built a snowman in the garden, where the pool had been, and they named him Mr. Snow, the same name they had given him three years ago, and they put Clara's old red scarf around his neck, and they gave him a carrot nose, and coal eyes, and they stood back, and they looked at him, and Lily said, "He looks the same as he did last year. And the year before. Do you think he'll remember us, next year?"
"Of course he will," Ivy said. "Snowmen always remember. They just melt, and then they come back, every winter, the same as before. Like us. We went away, and we came back. And we'll always come back. That's what family means."
Clara, watching from the kitchen window, thought about the three winters she had lived through since she came home, and the winter before that, in the room under the pool, and the winters before that, when she had been a little girl, in her grandmother's house, learning to read, learning to knock, and she thought about how winters come, and winters go, and how the snow melts, and the roses bloom, and the garden grows, and how, in the end, the only thing that matters is who is standing beside you, in the snow, in the garden, in the kitchen, in the dark, knocking back, two knocks, and then two knocks, saying, I'm here. I'm here. I'm here.
Ethan came into the kitchen with two cups of coffee, and he set one down in front of her, and he kissed the top of her head, and he said, "Good morning."
"Good morning," Clara said, and she smiled, and she took his hand, and they stood there together, at the window, watching their daughters, nine years old now, tall and strong and laughing, building a snowman in the garden where a pool used to be, and the house was warm, and the fire was burning, and the snow was falling, soft and white, outside the window, and it was, Clara thought, an ordinary morning, in an ordinary winter, in an ordinary house, and it was the most extraordinary thing in the world, because it was theirs, and it was home, and it would be home, for as long as they lived.
Meredith wrote to Ivy every year on her birthday, from the corrections facility, one letter a year, in a plain white envelope, with no return address, only a stamp, and Clara read each one first, alone, on the terrace, in the morning, before she filed it in the tin box, with the birth ledger, and the photograph, and the bracelets, and Henry's letter, and Rose's letters, and she did not show them to Ivy, not yet, because Ivy was still too young, and because some letters need to wait until the person they were written for is old enough to understand them.
The letters were short, and careful, and they never asked for anything. Meredith wrote about the cottage, about the roses, about the drawings Ivy had made, about the first word she had said, about the night she had cried, and Meredith had held her, all night, afraid to put her down. She wrote about the years she had spent raising Ivy, and how she had loved her, and how she had been wrong, about so many things, and how she hoped, one day, when Ivy was older, when she was ready, she would understand, and she would forgive her, not because Meredith deserved it, but because Ivy deserved to be free.