Ethan had not been back to the lake since the night Clara disappeared, since the morning the boat was found, empty, drifting, with a white ribbon tied to the railing, and he had avoided it, the way a man avoids a place where something terrible happened, driving the long way around, never looking at the water, never stopping at the dock, never letting Lily go near it, because the lake had taken his wife, and he could not forgive it.
But in the summer, two years after Clara came home, Clara said, "I want to go back. I want to see the lake. I want the girls to see it. I want us to go, together, as a family, and I want to look at the water, and I want to understand that it is just water, that it never took me, that no one took me, except a person, and that person is gone now, and the lake is just a lake."
They went on a Saturday morning, early, before the heat, and they drove to the dock, and Ethan parked the car, and they walked down to the water, and Clara stood at the edge, looking out at the lake, flat and gray in the morning light, and she was quiet for a long time, and then she said, "It's smaller than I remembered. I thought it was enormous. I thought it went on forever. But it's just a lake. It's just water."
Joseph Kline was there, on the dock, mending a net, and he looked up, and he saw them, and he stood up, and he took off his cap, and he said, "Mrs. Marsh. I heard you came home. I'm glad. I'm very glad."
"Thank you, Mr. Kline," Clara said. "Thank you for telling the truth. About the boat. About the ribbon. It mattered. It mattered more than you know."
Joseph nodded, and he looked at the girls, in their matching dresses, green and blue, skipping stones on the water, laughing, and he said, "Those your girls?"
"They are," Clara said. "Both of them. Lily and Ivy. Twins."
Joseph smiled, a slow, weathered smile, and he said, "Well. The lake gives back, sometimes. Not often. But sometimes. And I'm glad it gave you back."
They rented a boat, a small one, with an engine that worked, and Ethan rowed them out, into the middle of the lake, and the girls trailed their hands in the water, and Clara sat in the bow, with her face to the sun, and her hair blowing, and the white ribbon tied in it, and she laughed, a real laugh, and Ethan laughed, and the girls laughed, and the boat rocked, gently, on the water, and the lake, which had once been a place of fear, became, in that moment, just a lake, just water, just a Saturday morning, with a family, in a boat, together, and Clara thought about the night Meredith had drugged her, and put her in a boat, and told her she was going to die, and she thought about how, in the end, Meredith had been wrong, about everything, and how the lake had not taken her, and the dark had not kept her, and the water had not closed over her, and how she was here, in a boat, on the lake, alive, with her husband, and her daughters, and the sun on her face, and that was the whole of it. That was all there was.
Ethan found the letter in the study, in the winter, two years after Clara came home, in a drawer he had not opened since his father died, a drawer full of old invoices, and paint samples, and a broken tape measure, and at the very bottom, an envelope, sealed, yellowed, with his name on it, in his father's handwriting, in ink that had faded to brown.
He did not open it at once. He sat at the desk, and he looked at it, for a long time, and he thought about his father, about Henry Marsh, who had built the house, and the company, and the shelter under the pool, and who had stolen a baby, and forged a certificate, and paid a fixer, and who had died four years ago, believing, to the end, that he had done the right thing, that a divided house falls, that a company can only have one heir, that some children matter more than others.
He opened it, finally, in the evening, with Clara beside him, and he read it aloud, slowly, because his father's handwriting was hard to read, and because he wanted Clara to hear it, word for word.