Ivy nodded, very slightly, and Mrs. Alvarez smiled, and she said, "Then you'll sit by the window, where the light is best, and you can draw us a picture of your garden, and we'll hang it on the wall, so everyone can see it."
Ivy sat by the window, and Lily sat beside her, and the morning went by, and Ivy drew a picture of the garden, with six rose bushes, and sunflowers along the fence, and two little girls holding hands, and a woman with long hair standing behind them, and when Mrs. Alvarez hung it on the wall, Ivy stood and looked at it for a long time, and then she turned to Lily, and she whispered, "Did I do it right? Is that what a family looks like?"
"Yes," Lily said. "That's exactly what a family looks like."
At three o'clock, Clara was waiting at the gate, and Ivy ran to her, and she did not walk, she ran, and she threw her arms around Clara, and she said, "Mommy! Mommy, I did it! I went to school! And Mrs. Alvarez hung my picture on the wall! And Lily sat next to me the whole time! And tomorrow I get to go again!"
Clara picked her up, and held her, and laughed, and cried a little, too, because six years ago, a nurse had taken a baby away and said she didn't make it, and now that baby was six years old, and she had gone to school, and she had drawn a picture of her family, and it was hanging on a wall where everyone could see it, and no one, not Henry Marsh, not Silas Grant, not Meredith Vane, not anyone, could ever make her disappear again.
The lullaby had no name. Clara had made it up when Lily was a baby, on a night when Lily would not sleep, when the house was quiet and the rain was falling on the roof, and Clara had walked the hallway with Lily in her arms, humming, making it up as she went, four notes, the same four notes, over and over, until Lily's eyes closed, and Clara's own eyes closed, and they both slept, standing up, in the hallway, leaning against the wall.
She had never written it down. She had never needed to. It was in her hands, in her throat, in the way she rocked, in the way Lily knew it, in the way Lily had taught it to the wall, two knocks and then two knocks, so that her mother would know she was still there, on the other side, listening.
After Clara came home, after the hospital, after the hearing, after the pool was filled in, Lily asked her to sing it again, and Clara did, on the first night they were all home together, in the girls' big bed, with Lily on one side and Ivy on the other, and Ethan sitting in the chair by the door, and Marta standing in the hallway, listening, and Ray, downstairs, pretending not to listen, and Tomás, in the garden, looking up at the window, and the whole house, it seemed, holding its breath.
Clara sang the four notes, low and slow, and Lily closed her eyes, and Ivy, who had never heard the lullaby before, who had only ever heard Meredith's songs, different songs, sadder songs, lay very still, and listened, and then, very quietly, she began to hum along, getting the notes wrong, and then getting them right, and then getting them so right that Clara stopped singing, and listened, and Ivy sang the lullaby, all four notes, over and over, until her voice grew soft, and her eyes grew heavy, and she fell asleep, in her mother's bed, in her sister's arms, in her own house, for the first time in her life, without being afraid.
Clara sat there for a long time after they were both asleep, looking at them, at their faces, so alike and so different, Lily with her mother's chin, Ivy with her mother's eyes, both of them with their father's dark hair, both of them breathing, slow and even, in the lamplight, and she thought about the year she had spent in the room under the pool, and how she had sung the lullaby to herself, in the dark, to keep from going mad, to keep from forgetting who she was, and she thought about how, for a year, the lullaby had been the only thing she had, and now it was here, in this room, in these two girls, and it was no longer hers alone, it was theirs, and it would be theirs for as long as they lived.