Now she was warm. Now she was home. Now her daughters were making snow angels in the garden, and her husband was bringing her tea, and the fire was burning, and the house smelled of bread, and the snow was falling, soft and white, outside the window, and Clara understood, finally, what the winter had been for: not to punish her, not to break her, but to teach her what warmth was, so that when it came back, she would know it, and she would never, ever take it for granted again.
On Christmas morning, the girls came down the stairs in their nightdresses, barefoot, their hair wild, and they ran to the tree, and they tore open their presents, and Lily got a bicycle, blue, and Ivy got a bicycle, green, and they screamed, and they hugged Clara, and they hugged Ethan, and they hugged Marta, and they hugged each other, and Clara sat on the floor, in the middle of the wrapping paper, with her daughters in her lap, and she thought about the Christmas before, when she had been in the room under the pool, and there had been no tree, and no presents, and no one to hug, and she had sung the lullaby, very quietly, to herself, and she had thought about Lily, opening her presents, alone, without her mother, and she had cried, and she had kept singing, and now, here she was, on the floor, in the wrapping paper, with both her daughters in her lap, and it was Christmas, and it was morning, and it was home.
In the spring, the school put on a play, a play about two sisters who lived in a house by the sea, and who were separated by a storm, and who found each other again, years later, by following the sound of a song, and Mrs. Alvarez asked Lily and Ivy to play the two sisters, because, she said, "You two look like sisters, and you act like sisters, and you are sisters, and the play needs sisters who are real."
Lily and Ivy rehearsed for weeks, in the garden, in the kitchen, in the bedroom, learning their lines, learning the song, a simple song, four notes, over and over, the same four notes Clara had sung to Lily when she was a baby, the same four notes Ivy had learned in the cottage, from Meredith, who had learned them from a photograph, from a memory, from a sister she had lost when she was five.
On the night of the play, the school hall was full, parents and grandparents and teachers and friends, and Clara sat in the front row, with Ethan beside her, and Marta behind her, and Ray beside her, and Tomás at the back, standing, because he did not like to sit, and the curtain went up, and Lily and Ivy walked onto the stage, in matching dresses, green and blue, and they said their lines, clearly, without stumbling, and they sang the song, four notes, over and over, and their voices, together, were so clear, and so true, that the whole hall went silent, and Clara cried, and Ethan held her hand, and Marta cried, and Ray cried, although he would deny it later, and when the play was over, when the sisters had found each other, when the curtain came down, the whole hall stood up, and cheered, and cheered, and would not stop cheering, until Lily and Ivy came out, and bowed, together, holding hands, and the cheering got louder, and Clara thought, this is what a play is supposed to do. This is what a story is supposed to do. It is supposed to tell the truth, in a way that makes people stand up, and cheer, and believe, even for a moment, that the world is fair, and that sisters who are lost can be found, and that songs, sung in the dark, can be heard.
After the play, after the applause, after the girls had changed out of their costumes, Mrs. Alvarez came to Clara, and she said, "Mrs. Marsh, your daughters are remarkable. They have a gift. Not just for acting, but for listening to each other. They listen, and they answer, and they never once lose the thread. I have never seen two children listen to each other the way they do."
"They learned it young," Clara said. "They learned it through a wall. Through water. Through concrete. They learned that if you listen hard enough, and you knock, someone will knock back. And they never forgot it."