The letter arrived on a Tuesday in January, in a plain white envelope, with no return address, only a stamp, and a postmark from the corrections facility forty miles away, and Clara knew what it was before she opened it, because there was only one person who would write to her from there, and only one thing that person would have to say.
She read it alone, on the terrace, in the morning, while Ethan was at the site, and the girls were at school, and the house was quiet, and the garden was bare, waiting for spring.
It was not a long letter. Meredith did not make excuses. She did not ask for anything about the trial. She did not ask Clara to forgive her. She wrote, mostly, about Ivy. About the night Ivy was born, and the way she had cried, a thin, furious cry, like a kitten, and the way Meredith had held her, all night, afraid to put her down, afraid she would stop breathing. About the first word Ivy had said, which was "rose," because the cottage had roses, and Ivy had pointed at them, and Meredith had told her the word, and Ivy had said it back, perfectly, and Meredith had cried. About the drawings Ivy had made, hundreds of them, houses and gardens and a woman with long hair, and how Meredith had kept every one, in a box under her bed, and how she had looked at them, some nights, and wondered what Ivy was drawing, and who she was drawing it for.
"I am not asking you to let me see her," Meredith wrote. "I am not asking you to write back. I am asking you for one thing, and only one thing: when she is older, when she is ready, tell her that I loved her. Tell her that the woman who raised her loved her, and kept her safe, and sang to her, and that she was not a mistake, and not a secret, and not a key. Tell her she was a little girl, and she was loved, and that is the whole of it. That is all I have to ask. That is all I have left."
Clara folded the letter, and she put it back in the envelope, and she sat on the terrace for a long time, looking at the garden, at the bare rose bushes, at the stone path, at the place where the pool had been, and she thought about her sister, sitting in a cell forty miles away, writing a letter to a child she would never see again, and she thought about Ivy, at school, drawing a picture of her family, and she thought about the difference between the two of them, between Meredith and herself, and she understood, finally, what that difference was.
Meredith had loved Ivy, and she had used her. Clara loved Ivy, and she would never use her. That was the whole of it. That was all there was.
She took the letter inside, and she put it in the tin box, with the birth ledger, and the photograph, and the bracelets, and she closed the lid, and she put the box on the shelf in the study, where it would be safe, where Ivy could find it one day, when she was older, when she was ready, and where she could read, in her aunt's own handwriting, that she had been loved, and that she had been wanted, and that she had never, not for one minute, been alone.
She did not answer the letter. She did not need to. Some letters are not meant to be answered. Some letters are meant to be kept, and to be read, years later, by the person they were written for, and to be understood, then, in a way they cannot be understood now.
Clara's white ribbon had been in the pool for a year, caught on the hatch, floating in the water, and when Ethan drained the pool, he found it, tangled in the drain, faded by the chlorine, but still white, still hers, and he brought it to her, in the hospital, on the second day, and he put it in her hand, and she held it, and she cried, because it was the last thing she had worn before Meredith took her, the ribbon she had tied in her hair on the morning of the anniversary dinner, the ribbon Lily had watched her tie, a hundred times, standing on a stool in the bathroom, watching her mother get ready, asking, "Can I wear one too, Mommy? Can I have a ribbon like yours?"