My Six-Year-Old Daughter Interrupted My Proposal, Screaming That Her Mother Was Trapped Under The Pool — Then I Found A Locked Metal Hatch Beneath The Water

Chapter 5

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"She's brave," Clara said, and she smiled through her tears. "She's braver than either of us. Now listen to me, Ethan, because we don't have much time. Meredith has a plan for tonight. The wedding isn't tomorrow. The papers are tonight. She's going to get you to sign guardianship papers while you're still shaken from the proposal, while the guests are still here as witnesses. And there's something else. Something I only learned a few weeks before she took me. Something about Lily."

She took his hand, and her fingers were cold, and she pressed them hard, as if she were afraid he would let go.

"Lily has a twin sister, Ethan. We had two daughters. Two girls, born six minutes apart, and I only ever got to hold one of them."

The boat had been found drifting on the lake the morning after Clara disappeared, empty, its engine idling, a single white ribbon caught on the railing, fluttering in the wind. That was the story Ethan had been told, and he had believed it, because there was no reason not to believe it. The lake was deep and cold. The sheriff's divers had searched for three days. There was no body, but there often wasn't, not in that lake, not in October, when the water turned over and the currents ran strange and deep.

He remembered the funeral, the empty coffin, the photograph of Clara on the mantel, smiling in a yellow dress on the day Lily was born. He remembered the months after, the way the house had gone quiet, the way Lily had stopped asking where Mommy was and started asking instead whether Mommy could hear her if she knocked on the wall, and he had told her yes, of course, Mommy could always hear her, and he had thought he was comforting her.

Now, sitting on the edge of the narrow bed in the room under the pool, holding Clara's hand, he understood that Lily had not been talking to a memory. She had been talking to the floor. She had been talking through the pipes, through the concrete, through six feet of water, to her mother, who was knocking back.

"Tell me about the girls," he said. "Tell me everything."

Clara closed her eyes. "It was six years ago, at Mercy General. The delivery was hard. I remember the lights, and the doctor's voice, and then someone saying, 'Two girls,' and then the room going very quiet. They put Lily in my arms. She was pink and furious and perfect. And then a nurse took the other baby away, and I asked where she was going, and someone said, 'She didn't make it, Mrs. Marsh. The smaller twin. I'm so sorry.' And I believed them, Ethan. I was tired, and I was drugged, and I believed them, because why would anyone lie about a thing like that?"

She opened her eyes again, and they were clear and hard, the way they had been when she used to argue with him about the business, about the house, about anything she believed in.

"But I never forgot her. I never forgot that there had been two. And fourteen months ago, I found the records. I was clearing out your father's study, looking for the deed to the lake house, and I found a file, a medical file, with my name on it, and inside it there were two birth certificates, Ethan. Two. One for Lily, and one for a second girl, born six minutes later, named by a nurse who wrote her name in pencil in the margin. Ivy. And there was a note, in your father's handwriting, saying the second child had been 'placed elsewhere, per arrangement.'"

"My father," Ethan said, slowly. "My father did this?"

"Your father believed that twins would divide the company," Clara said. "He told me once, years ago, when I was pregnant, that Marsh Builders could only have one heir, that a divided house falls. I thought he was talking about the business. I didn't know he meant our children. He paid a doctor to declare the second baby stillborn. He paid a fixer to take her away. And he paid Meredith, Ethan. That's how she found us. Your father's fixer gave the baby to Meredith, because she was my twin, because she was family, because she would keep quiet for money. And she did. For six years, she kept quiet, and she raised our daughter in a little cottage across town, and she told her she had no family, and no name that mattered, and no one who would ever come for her."

News in the same category

My Six-Year-Old Daughter Interrupted My Proposal, Screaming That Her Mother Was Trapped Under The Pool — Then I Found A Locked Metal Hatch Beneath The Water

45 Part