Clara had promised her she could, one day, when she was older, when her hair was long enough, and then she had disappeared, and the ribbon had gone with her, into the dark, under the pool, and Lily had grown up without it, and without her.
Now Clara tied the ribbon in her hair again, on a morning in February, six months after she came home, and she stood in front of the mirror in the bedroom, and she looked at herself, at her short hair, growing back, at her thin face, filling out, at her eyes, clear again, and she thought about the woman she had been, a year ago, and the woman she was now, and she understood that they were the same woman, and also, that they were not, that a year in the dark changes a person, and that the person who comes out is not the person who went in, but someone stronger, and sadder, and more grateful, all at once.
Lily came into the bedroom, and she saw the ribbon, and her eyes went wide, and she said, "Mommy! Your ribbon! You found it!"
"Daddy found it," Clara said. "In the pool. And he brought it to me. And now I'm wearing it again. And you know what? I think you're old enough now. I think your hair is long enough now. Would you like a ribbon of your own?"
Lily nodded, so hard her whole body nodded with her, and Clara went to the drawer, and she took out a second ribbon, a blue one, and a third, a green one, and she tied the blue one in Lily's hair, and the green one in Ivy's, when Ivy came in, rubbing her eyes, in her nightdress, asking what was happening, and Clara tied the ribbons, and she stood back, and she looked at her daughters, in their ribbons, blue and green, the colors of the bracelets, the colors of the cakes, the colors of the day they were born, and she thought about the photograph in the tin box, of two babies with ribbons on their wrists, and she thought about how, six years later, the ribbons were still there, still tying them together, still saying, in a language only they understood: we are sisters. We were always sisters. We will always be sisters.
Ethan came to the door, with coffee, and he looked at the three of them, in their ribbons, and he smiled, and he said, "You look beautiful. All three of you."
"We are beautiful," Lily said, with the absolute confidence of a six-year-old who has just been given a ribbon by her mother. "We're the most beautiful family in the whole world."
And Clara laughed, and she picked up her daughters, one in each arm, thin as she still was, strong as she had become, and she carried them down the stairs, into the kitchen, into the morning, into the rest of their lives.
Marta Ellison had worked for the Marsh family for twenty years, and in twenty years she had seen many things, and she had said nothing about most of them, because a housekeeper who says everything she sees does not stay a housekeeper for twenty years.
But after the hearing, after the verdict, after the pool was filled in, Marta sat down at the kitchen table with Clara, and with a cup of tea, and she told her what she had seen, in the year Clara was gone, and in the months before that, when Meredith first came to the house, and Marta had known, from the first day, that something was wrong.
"I knew she wasn't you," Marta said, simply, the way she said everything, plainly, without flourish. "I knew it the first morning she came down for breakfast. She asked for coffee with milk. You never took milk. You took honey. And she held her cup in her left hand. You're right-handed. And she called Lily 'sweetie.' You never called her that. You called her 'baby,' or 'love,' but never 'sweetie.' Little things. A hundred little things. And I thought, she's grieving, she's changed, people change when they lose someone. But I knew. In my heart, I knew."
"Why didn't you say anything?" Clara asked, and her voice was gentle, because she was not angry, she was only tired, and sad, and grateful that Marta was still here, still making tea, still telling the truth.