"Yes," Clara said, and she knelt down beside her, and she put her hands on Ivy's shoulders, and she looked her in the eye, the way she had learned to do, the way a mother learns to do when she is telling a child something true and hard at the same time. "This is where I was. And now it's a garden. Do you know why we made it a garden, Ivy?"
"Because gardens grow," Ivy said, slowly, the way she said things when she was thinking them through, word by word. "And water doesn't. Water just stays."
"That's right," Clara said. "Water just stays. But gardens grow. And we're going to grow here, all of us, together, for a long time."
Lily, who had been listening, came and stood on Clara's other side, and she put her hand on Clara's shoulder, and she said, "Can we plant something else? Can we plant sunflowers? Mommy, can we plant sunflowers all along the fence, so tall that you can see them from the road?"
"We can plant whatever you want," Clara said. "This is your garden now. Both of yours."
They planted sunflowers the next weekend, and sweet peas, and lavender, and by May the garden was a riot of color, yellow and purple and green, and the neighbors stopped to look over the fence, and the postman said it was the prettiest garden on the street, and Clara, standing at the kitchen window with a cup of tea, thought about the room under the pool, and how it was gone now, filled with concrete, and how the earth above it was full of roots, and how roots, given time, will break through anything, even concrete, even secrets, even a year in the dark.
Ethan came up behind her and put his arms around her, and she leaned back against him, and they stood there for a long time, watching the girls in the garden, Lily showing Ivy how to tie a sunflower to a stake, Ivy showing Lily how to make a daisy chain, the two of them laughing, their hair in the sun, their hands in the earth, and Clara thought about the night she had spent in the room under the pool, counting the days by the sound of the pump, and she thought about how she had promised herself, on the worst nights, that if she ever got out, she would plant a garden, and she would never, ever let anyone tell her daughters that they were alone.
"I kept my promise," she said, quietly, to no one in particular, to the garden, to the house, to herself. "I kept it."
Ivy started school on a Monday morning in September, and she had never been to school before, and she was terrified, and she did not say she was terrified, because she had learned, in six years in a cottage, that you do not say when you are afraid, you simply lie very still and wait for it to pass. But Clara knew. Clara could see it in the way Ivy held her lunchbox, too tightly, in the way she kept touching the strap of her backpack, in the way she stood at the gate and looked at the playground, at all the children running and shouting, as if she were looking at a country she had heard about but had never visited.
"You don't have to go," Clara said, kneeling down beside her, at the gate, in front of the school, while the other parents hurried past with their children. "If you're not ready, you don't have to go today. We can go home. We can try again tomorrow. There's no rush, Ivy. There's no rush at all."
Ivy looked at the playground for a long moment. And then she looked at Lily, who was standing beside her, holding her hand, wearing a matching dress, green, the same green as Ivy's, because they had chosen them together, the night before, and Lily had said, "If we match, everyone will know we're sisters, and no one will be able to pretend we're not."
"I want to go," Ivy said, and her voice was small, but it was steady. "Lily will be with me. Won't you, Lily?"
"Of course I will," Lily said, and she squeezed Ivy's hand. "I'll sit next to you. And if anyone is mean, I'll tell them. And if anyone asks where you were before, I'll tell them you were with Aunt Meredith, and now you're home, and that's all anyone needs to know."
The teacher, a kind woman named Mrs. Alvarez, met them at the classroom door, and she knelt down, and she said, "You must be Ivy. Lily has told us all about you. She says you're the best drawer in the whole world. Is that true?"