Audrey's voice stayed low and reasonable, which frightened Ethan more than shouting would have. "Ethan, darling, think about what you're doing. Lily is six years old. She misses her mother. She's invented a game. If you tear up the pool on the anniversary of Clara's death, in front of all our friends, you'll humiliate her, and yourself, and there will be nothing down there."
"Then there will be nothing down there," Ethan said, "and I'll apologize to everyone. But I'm going to look."
He took the towel from Ray and dried his face, and as he did he noticed something he should have noticed a year ago, or eight months ago, or any of the hundred mornings Audrey had poured his coffee and asked about his day: her dress was perfectly dry. She had been standing beside the pool for an hour. Everyone else had damp hems from the grass, wet footprints on the stone. Audrey's shoes were spotless, her dress uncreased, as if she had been standing somewhere else entirely, watching from a distance, waiting for something.
It took Ray nine minutes to get the guests inside, and in those nine minutes Ethan stood at the edge of the pool and watched Audrey, and Audrey watched him back, and neither of them said a word. Lily sat on the stone coping with Nadia's arm around her, her bare feet dangling over the water, whispering to herself, counting under her breath: one, two, one, two.
Ray came back with a ring of old keys, the brass ones, the ones Henry Marsh had kept on a hook in the garden shed since the house was built, each one tagged in his father's handwriting: POOL HOUSE. PUMP ROOM. SHED. CELLAR.
"There's one more," Ray said, holding up a key that was smaller than the rest, dark with age. The tag on it read, in faded ink: BELOW.
Ethan took it. It was cold in his hand, colder than the other keys, as if it had been waiting a long time to be held.
"Ray," he said, "lock the house. Nobody in or out until I say so. Keep Audrey in the drawing room where I can see her. Nadia, take Lily upstairs, and stay with her. Lily—" He knelt down again, and this time he looked his daughter in the eye, and he made his voice as steady as he could. "You did the right thing. You did exactly the right thing. Now I need you to go upstairs and stay with Nadia, and whatever you hear, you stay there until I come for you. Do you understand?"
Lily nodded, her eyes huge. "Will you let her out?"
"Yes," Ethan said. "I will let her out."
He waited until Nadia had taken her up the stairs and the French doors had closed, and then he took the keys and walked around to the side of the house, to the small door set into the foundation that he had always assumed was a pump room, the door he had not opened since his father died four years ago.
The key marked BELOW fitted the lock. It turned with a sound like a sigh, and the door opened onto a narrow stairway going down, concrete steps, a single bare bulb that Ray switched on from the top of the stairs, and at the bottom, a corridor that ran under the garden, under the lawn, under the pool itself.
Ethan went down with Ray behind him, and at the end of the corridor there was a steel door, and on the steel door, set at eye level, was a small round window of thick glass, and behind the glass, lit by a single low lamp, was a room.
A bed, neatly made, with a thin blanket folded at the foot. A small table with a cup and a plate. A shelf of books, their spines faded. Drawings pinned to the wall, dozens of them, in crayon and pencil, houses and gardens and a woman with long hair standing beside a little girl. And sitting on the edge of the bed, very still, her hands folded in her lap, her hair cut short and uneven, her face thin and pale, was a woman Ethan had buried a year ago.
She looked up at the window. Her eyes found his. And she smiled, the way she had smiled at him on their wedding day, as if she had been waiting for him to find the door, and had never once doubted that he would.
"Clara," Ethan said, and the word came out of him like something breaking open.