"Yes," Clara said. "I promised you I would. And I keep my promises, Meredith. That's the difference between us."
Meredith nodded, and the officers led her away, and Clara watched her go, and Ethan put his arm around her, and Lily took her hand, and Ivy took her other hand, and the four of them walked out of the courthouse together, into the November sunlight, and the air smelled of rain, and the sky was gray, and it was, for the first time in a long time, an ordinary day.
They drained the pool on a Saturday morning, and it took all day, and the water ran out into the garden, and the garden drank it, and by evening the pool was empty, a great blue hole in the ground, and Ethan stood at the edge of it with Lily and Ivy, and he looked down at the floor, at the circle where the hatch had been, at the small square of glass where Lily had pressed her hand, and he thought about the year Clara had spent underneath it, and the six years Ivy had spent believing she had no one, and he thought about how easy it would be to hate the pool, to hate the house, to hate everything that had happened in it.
But he did not hate it. He had built the house with his father. He had married Clara in the garden. Lily had taken her first steps on the lawn. And now, Ivy was going to take her first steps here too, in a house that was finally, after six years, and fourteen months, and one long night, theirs.
On Monday, the workmen came, and they cut the hatch out with torches, and they filled the room underneath with concrete, and they filled the pool with earth, and they leveled it, and they planted grass, and by the end of the week, there was no pool at all, only a garden, a flat green lawn where the water had been, and a flower bed where the deep end had been, and a stone path where the diving board had been.
Lily and Ivy watched the workmen from the kitchen window, and they asked a hundred questions, and Ethan answered them all, and when the workmen had gone, the girls went out into the garden, and they ran across the grass where the pool had been, and they laughed, and they fell down, and they got up again, and they ran some more, and Clara watched them from the kitchen door, and she thought about the room under the pool, and how it was no longer a room at all, but just ground, solid ground, ground that her daughters could run on, and she thought that was the best thing she had ever seen.
The garden began with roses. Not the roses Meredith had grown in the cottage on Alder Street, tight red buds behind a white fence, but the roses Rose Delaney had grown, the ones Clara remembered from her grandmother's garden, pale yellow, almost white in the morning light, with a scent that came to you before you saw them.
Clara bought them on a Saturday morning in March, six plants in black plastic pots, and she carried them home in the back of the car, and Lily and Ivy carried them, one at a time, out to the flat green lawn where the pool had been, and Ethan dug the holes, and Marta brought out a jug of water, and Tomás Rivera, who had said almost nothing in thirty years, stood at the edge of the lawn with his arms folded and said, "Deeper. The roots need room. You're planting a garden, not a grave."
Clara laughed, and she dug deeper, and the girls helped, their hands in the earth, their knees in the grass, and by lunchtime there were six rose bushes in a row along the place where the deep end had been, and a stone path where the diving board had been, and a wooden bench where Ethan had put it, under the old oak, where Clara used to sit in the mornings with her coffee, before any of it happened.
"This is where the water was," Ivy said, standing in the middle of the lawn, looking down at her shoes, at the grass, at the roses. "This is where Mommy was. Underneath."