Later, when the guests had gone, when the girls were in their big bed, when the house was quiet, Ethan and Clara sat on the terrace, with two glasses of wine, and they looked at the garden, at the roses, at the sunflowers, at the stone path, and Ethan said, "Do you ever think about her? About Meredith?"
"Every day," Clara said. "I think about the little girl she was, five years old, sent away, forgotten, and I think about the woman she became, and I think about how close we came, how close I came, to being her. If Rose had chosen differently. If the aunt had lived in a bigger house. If any one thing had gone differently. I could have been the one in the cottage. I could have been the one who buried her sister alive. And that frightens me, Ethan. It frightens me more than anything that happened to me in that room. Because it means the difference between us was never who we were. It was only what happened to us. And what happened to us was luck. Just luck."
Ethan took her hand, and he held it, and he said, "Then we'll be lucky together. For the rest of our lives. We'll be lucky, and we'll be grateful, and we'll never, ever take it for granted."
In the morning, the garden was full of new flowers. The roses had bloomed overnight, pale yellow, almost white in the morning light, and the sunflowers had opened, and the lavender was in bloom, and the whole garden smelled of summer, even though it was only April, and Clara stood at the kitchen window with a cup of tea, and she watched the girls run out into the garden in their nightdresses, barefoot, laughing, chasing each other around the rose bushes, and she thought about the morning, a year ago, when she had woken in a damp locked room with no windows, and a voice on a speaker had told her she was dead, and she had believed it, for a moment, for a terrible moment, she had believed it.
She had not believed it for long. She had sung the lullaby. She had knocked on the wall. She had widened the panel. She had waited. And now she was here, in her kitchen, in her house, with her daughters in the garden, and her husband bringing her coffee, and the whole ordinary, miraculous morning stretching out in front of her, and she understood, finally, what she had been fighting for, all along.
Not revenge. Not justice. Not even the truth, although the truth mattered, and justice mattered, and revenge, if she was honest, had crossed her mind, on the worst nights, in the dark. What she had been fighting for was this: a morning, in a kitchen, with tea, and coffee, and two little girls in nightdresses, running in a garden, where a pool used to be.
Ethan came into the kitchen with two cups of coffee, and he set one down in front of her, and he kissed the top of her head, and he said, "Good morning."
"Good morning," Clara said, and she smiled, and she took his hand, and they stood there together, at the window, watching their daughters, and the garden, and the new flowers, and the sun coming up over Cedar Bay, and the house, quiet around them, and ordinary, and theirs.
Outside, Lily knocked on the garden wall, two knocks, and then two knocks, and Ivy knocked back, two knocks, and then two knocks, and Clara laughed, and she knocked on the kitchen window, two knocks, and then two knocks, and the girls laughed, and they knocked back, and the whole house, it seemed, was knocking, two knocks, and then two knocks, a song with no words, a song that meant, I'm here. I'm here. I'm here. And I love you. And I'm never leaving again.
The shelter had been built in 1963, in the coldest winter anyone in Cedar Bay could remember, when the news was full of missiles and the sky felt closer than it should, and Henry Marsh, who was thirty years old and had just started his building company, had decided that his family would survive, whatever happened, and that the best way to survive was to dig a hole under the house and fill it with concrete and tinned food and bottled water, and to tell no one about it, except the one man who had helped him dig it.