She Walked Into Her Neighbor's House Over a Leaf Blower

Chapter 10

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Elena listened. Nancy would give her that, later, when she tried to remember the conversation fairly, because Elena did not interrupt and she did not roll her eyes, and she stood there with the blower hanging at her side and her hair coming loose from its tie, and she listened the way a person listens when they are trying to understand what is being asked of them rather than simply waiting for their turn to speak. But when Nancy had finished, when she had laid out her case about the noise and the afternoons and the way a home was meant to be a place of rest, Elena answered in a voice that was just as steady, and she said that the rules allowed electric equipment until eight in the evening, and that she had checked, and that she was well within that time. She said it without heat, without triumph, the way a person states a fact they have already looked up because they wanted to be sure, and Nancy felt the ground shift under her feet, because she had not expected Elena to have the rule ready, and she had not expected the rule to be so plain.

Nancy had the rules too. She had them in a folder in the drawer of her desk, the way she had kept every important paper for thirty-one years, in folders labeled in her neat, slanted handwriting, and she had read them more than once, because that was what you did when you lived in a place governed by rules. She knew about the equipment-hours rule. She knew it allowed electric equipment until eight. But she also knew there was another clause, and she had found it the night after the first complaint, when she had sat at her kitchen table with the folder open and a lamp burning low, reading the pages the way she used to read a student's essay, looking for the sentence that would hold. The clause said that residents should not cause excessive or persistent noise, and Nancy had read those words and felt something click into place, because excessive was a word with room in it, and persistent was a word with room in it, and a rule with room in it could be read in more than one way.

She said so, standing at the edge of the property with her arms folded and the late afternoon sun slanting across the fence, and she watched Elena's face as she said it, and she saw the small change there, the way Elena's eyebrows came together, not in anger but in a kind of careful attention, as if she were listening to a patient describe a pain that did not quite match the injury. Elena said that the blower was not excessive, that she used it for ten or fifteen minutes at a time, that she had a mother who needed a clear patio and a daughter who needed to get to her homework, and that she tried to be considerate, and Nancy heard the reasonableness in her voice and felt, at the same time, the stubbornness rising in her own chest, because reasonableness was not the same as agreement, and a person could be reasonable and still be wrong.

They talked for a while longer, standing there on the boundary between their two homes, and the conversation went the way such conversations go, in circles, each woman returning to the words that mattered most to her. Nancy returned to the clause about excessive or persistent noise, and she said it slowly, as if the slowness would make the meaning clearer, and Elena returned to the equipment-hours rule, and she said it just as slowly, as if the same slowness would do the same work for her. Neither of them raised her voice. Neither of them said anything unkind. But the space between them had changed, and Nancy could feel it, the way a teacher can feel the moment a classroom stops being a room full of children and becomes a room full of sides.

News in the same category

She Walked Into Her Neighbor's House Over a Leaf Blower

45 Part