She thought about Elena while she waited, because waiting gave her time to think, and she tried to be fair in her thinking, the way she had always tried to be fair when she marked a student's work. Elena was not a cruel neighbor. Nancy knew that. She had seen Elena help Sofia up the front steps on a rainy morning, holding the old woman's elbow with one hand and the cane with the other, and she had seen her kneel beside the patio to pull a weed from between the stones, and she had seen her wave to Maya as the girl came home from school with her backpack slung over one shoulder. Elena was a physical therapist, and Nancy had heard, from other neighbors, that she was good at her job, that she was patient with old people and gentle with children, and that she stayed late when a patient needed her. None of that made the blower quieter. None of that made the afternoons easier. But it made the problem harder to hold in her hands, because it was easier to be angry at a villain than it was to be angry at a tired woman with a mother and a daughter and a patio full of leaves.
She thought about Maya, too, the sixteen-year-old girl who lived in Unit 58, because Maya was the age of the students Nancy had taught in her last years, and she remembered the way girls that age walked, with their headphones in and their thoughts somewhere else, and she wondered whether Maya heard the blower at all, or whether she had learned to tune it out the way young people tuned out everything that did not belong to them. She thought about Sofia, the elderly mother with the cane, because Nancy understood what it meant to be old in a house that was not quite built for you, and she understood why Elena wanted the patio swept clean, and she felt the pull of sympathy even as she felt the pull of irritation, and the two pulls together made her tired in a way that had nothing to do with the noise.
She thought about Richard Coleman, as well, because his face stayed with her after the meeting, the polite nod and the patient voice and the way he had said that the peaceful enjoyment clause was for parties and loud music and prolonged construction, not for this. She turned his words over in her mind the way she used to turn over a student's answer that was almost right, looking for the place where it went wrong, and she found it, she thought, in the word repeated. Repeated was the key. A party was a nuisance because it happened again and again. Loud music was a nuisance because it came back night after night. Prolonged construction was a nuisance because it went on for weeks. And a blower, used every week, at the same times, in the same way, was also a thing that repeated, and if repetition was the test, then her log was the answer, and the answer was waiting to be written down, one entry at a time.
She remembered the classrooms where she had taught, and the way she had learned to keep records there, too, because a teacher who did not keep records was a teacher who could not prove what she knew. She had kept attendance books with names and dates in columns so neat that a principal could read them at a glance. She had kept grade books with numbers in rows, and she had kept notes on the children who needed extra help, and the children who needed a firmer hand, and the children whose parents needed a phone call. She had kept those records not because she loved paperwork, but because she had learned that memory was a poor witness, and that a person who wanted to be believed needed something better than a feeling. She needed a page with a date on it. She needed a time. She needed a number. And now, sitting at her kitchen table with the notebook open in front of her, she was doing the same work she had done for thirty-one years, only the subject had changed, and the classroom had become her own house.
The evenings grew quiet after the log began, or perhaps they only seemed quieter because Nancy was listening for something else now, for the pattern rather than the noise, and the pattern gave her a reason to sit still. She made tea. She read her book. She watered the plants on her windowsill. She listened to the house settle around her, the small creaks and sighs of an old building, and she thought about the way a home was supposed to feel, and about the promise that Hawthorne Ridge had made to her when she moved in, that her home would be her own, that she could sit in it in peace, and she wondered whether that promise had ever meant what she thought it meant, or whether it had always been a piece of paper with words on it that could be read two ways.