It was the noise that got to her most, though she would not have said so if anyone had asked. She would have said it was the principle of the thing, and she would have believed it, because the principle of the thing was real to her. But underneath the principle, underneath the neat and reasonable words she used with herself, there was the simple fact of the noise, and the way it pressed on her. She had spent her working life in rooms full of noise — thirty children at a time, chairs scraping, pencils dropping, voices rising and falling — and she had been good at it, and she had loved it, and she had never once thought of herself as someone who could not bear noise. But that was a different kind of noise. That was noise she had chosen, noise with a purpose, noise she could direct. The noise of a place where she lived was supposed to be hers to manage. That was the bargain. You kept your home quiet, and your neighbors kept their homes quiet, and everyone went about their lives without stepping on anyone else's. That was what a neighborhood was.
She had not always lived like this. She had not always lived with a shared wall and a common yard and a parking lot where children played basketball under the lights. For most of her life she had lived in a house with a yard of her own, and the memory of that house was still so clear in her mind that she could walk through it without closing her eyes. She could see the hallway. She could see the kitchen with its chipped countertop that Harold had always meant to replace and never had. She could see the backyard, wide and uneven, with the grass Harold mowed in straight lines on Saturday mornings and the flower beds she had planted herself, year after year, learning by doing, losing a few plants and saving the rest. She could see the fence. The tall cedar fence. It had run along the back of the property, and along the sides, and it had been the thing that made the yard theirs. It had not been a high wall or a fortress. It had been a fence, weathered gray-brown, with a gate that stuck in the winter and swung free in the summer, and it had meant that when Nancy sat in her backyard with a book, she was sitting in her own place, and nobody else's noise reached her unless she wanted it to. She had not known, when she lived there, how much that mattered to her. She had thought of the fence as a fence. Now she thought of it as the shape of her life.
Thirty-two years. That was how long she and Harold had lived in that house outside Evanston. Thirty-two years of winters and summers, of Harold coming home with his briefcase and his stories from the office, of Nancy grading papers at the kitchen table long after the sun had gone down, of holidays with the table stretched out to fit everyone, of ordinary Tuesdays that no one remembered and that made up the whole of a life. She had raised her daughter in that house. She had watched her daughter grow from a child who left her shoes in the hallway to a young woman who left for good, and then she had watched her daughter come back with a life of her own, and grandchildren's drawings on the refrigerator, and opinions about how her parents ought to live. Nancy did not resent it. She loved her daughter, and she knew her daughter loved her, and she knew that love was the reason for everything that had happened since. But she also knew, in the quiet part of her mind where she was honest with herself, that the house had been hers in a way that nothing since had been, and that she had given it up not because she wanted to but because she had been afraid, and because her daughter had been afraid, and because fear, once it entered a family, had a way of making all the decisions.