The Little Girl in the Yellow Dress Who Pointed at the Pool and Said Her Mother Was Under the Water

Chapter 14

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"Simone—"

"She knocks," Simone said, and laughed again, breathless, her eyes brilliant, "she knocks and knocks — you should hear her from the service room, it goes right through the pipes, it's in the walls of this house like a *pulse* — and you sat at breakfast! With your coffee! Saying *Lily had a dream*! I could have—" Words failed her, or failed to be enough; she shook his shirt instead, hard, a woman shaking a rug. "Do you know what it costs to keep a secret in a house with a child? Children hear *everything*. They are all ears and no manners. I told her it was the pipes having dreams. I told her — and she believed me at breakfast and forgot by lunch, because she is six, and you—"

"Where is she?" Caleb said.

It came out of him quietly. He was vaguely aware that he should have seized her wrists, should have shouted for Lily to run, should have done any of the things a man does in the film of such a moment. Instead he sat on the coping with the water at his waist and his wife's fists in his shirt and asked the question that had been underneath every day of two years, and he asked it in the voice of a man asking directions in a town he has lived in all his life.

"And he thought, while the laugh was still ringing in the wet air between their faces, of the night of the party two years ago — the candles on this same deck, Elena in a white dress moving among their friends like something the evening had been arranged around; of the note found the next morning on the kitchen counter in writing so like hers that he had never questioned it, because Simone, who had copied her little sister's hand since they were girls sharing a desk, had read it aloud to him before he could hold it himself; of the police officer saying *no body, sir, which is hopeful, in a way*; of the private detective he had paid for four months and then, at Simone's urging — *let her be gone, Caleb, for Lily's sake, let the door close* — had paid no longer. The door. She had used the very word, in his own kitchen, with her hand on his arm, and he had thanked her for it. He had thanked her, and married her, and slept, and all the while the real door had been here, under the bright water where his daughter dangled her feet, tended and polished and faithfully locked.

"Where is Elena, Simone?""

The laughter stopped. It stopped the way a song stops when the needle is lifted — mid-phrase, leaving a ringing absence. Her eyes, wet-lashed, brilliant still, searched his face, and he saw her find in it whatever she found: not rage, not violence, none of the things she might have known how to use. Just the question, still standing there, unmoved by her laughter. Something in her seemed to recognise, too late, that the laugh had been a mistake — that it had told him the one thing her words had been arranged, for two years and into this very afternoon, to keep him from knowing: that there had never been a lover. That there had never been a note written by Elena's hand, or a leaving, or a life elsewhere being lived in thoughtless happiness while he poured his daughter's cereal. That it had all been kept, the way the house kept things. Under his hands. Under the water. Under the bright, ordinary surface of every single day.

"You know where she is," Simone whispered. "You put your hand on the lock. You tell me." Her grip tightened and relaxed, tightened and relaxed, as if her hands were thinking for her. "Down there. In grandfather's vault, where she always belonged, in the dark, hearing us. Hearing you. Do you understand what that's *like*, Caleb? Every footstep. Every dinner. Your wedding — my wedding — she heard the music through the pipes. I made sure the pipes carried it. I am not a monster. I fed her. I kept her. No one else in this family ever kept anything — mother let everything go, father let everything go, Elena let *you* go a hundred times in her mind before I ever—" She stopped. Her mouth worked. "It was supposed to end tonight. Clean. Ray at nine, and the pool drained for the winter, and a story with an ending. And your daughter had to sit on the edge with her feet in the water and *listen*."

"Tonight," Caleb repeated. The word moved very quietly through him, the way cold water moves through a crack. "What happens tonight?"

But Simone was looking past him suddenly, up at the deck, at Lily — and her whole face was reorganising itself again, the sister-aunt-wife coming back into it like a tide returning, because Simone's genius had never been the vault or the lock; it had been this, the face, the voice, the story told at breakfast. "Lily, darling," she called, sweet and carrying, "come here to Mommy, come away from the edge, darling, Daddy's had a fright—"

Lily did not move. Lily looked at her father.

News in the same category

The Little Girl in the Yellow Dress Who Pointed at the Pool and Said Her Mother Was Under the Water

45 Part