The Little Girl in the Yellow Dress Who Pointed at the Pool and Said Her Mother Was Under the Water

Chapter 17

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The story, as Simone had told it that night and a hundred times since — with the note propped on the kitchen counter to prove it — was that Elena had walked out on her marriage theatrically, the way women in stories do: left her ring on the dresser as a full stop. And there had been a ring on the dresser. Caleb had stood in their bedroom at two in the morning with two police officers and seen it there, a gold ring on the dark wood beside her hairbrush, and it had seemed to him the cruellest detail of the whole night.

He lifted the band to the light and turned it between his fingers. Inside, where the gold was protected from wear, the tiny engraved letters were still clear. He did not need to read them — he had paid for them by the letter — but he read them: the date of a wedding, and two initials, and between them a small, foolish, perfect ampersand.

The ring on the dresser had been a copy. Of course it had. You could buy such a ring anywhere; it was the most ordinary object in the world — that was its whole design. Simone, who planned, had bought a plain gold band in Elena's size and set it on the dresser where the police would see it, where he would see it, and it had done its work for two years. The wrong ring had sat ever since in a drawer of his own desk, and he had taken it out on some nights in the first year and felt accused by it. All that time the true one had been here, a few feet from where he ate his breakfast — carried against Simone's hip through every day of it, zipped into the coin pocket of her wallet, next to a single spare house key, its head wrapped in the green tape Simone used to mark her keys.

"Daddy?" Lily said. "What's that?"

He could not answer at first.

"That's Mommy's ring," he said at last, and saw her face understand before his own mind had finished doing it — because children do not have two years of a story mortared over the truth.

"Your mommy's," he said. "Your real mommy's. Elena's."

"Why does Mommy Simone have it in her purse?"

"I don't know yet," Caleb said, which was a lie in the shape of mercy, and even as he said it he could feel the knowing arriving, piece by piece, the way cold water rises. "Stay there, Lily. Stay right there."

He put the ring down on the table, carefully, in the sun, where he could see it; he did not trust his hands with it. Then he went back into the bag, because if the ring was there, there would be more. A woman who keeps the ring keeps the rest of the sentence too.

The second phone was in the deep zippered compartment along the back wall of the bag. His fingers found it by shape before his mind caught up: a phone, slim and cool, in a case he recognised.

He had known Elena's phone almost as well as her hands. The case had once been a clear, bright blue; the blue had gone cloudy with years. There was a crack across one corner from the afternoon she dropped it on the courthouse steps the day they signed for this house — she had been laughing too hard at her grandfather's lawyer, and the phone had gone down the steps in a clatter, and she had held up the cracked case like a trophy. "First blood to the house," she had said.

Caleb took the dead woman's phone out of her sister's handbag and held it in the sun.

It was not dead.

The screen lit at the touch of his thumb — a small, obedient flare of light that was somehow the most obscene thing yet, worse than the ring, worse than the door. A kept thing. A thing tended. The battery symbol showed nearly full. Somewhere in the ordinary machinery of their life there was a charger, and a habit, and a hand that took this phone out in private and kept it alive the way you water a plant you cannot bear to let die — or the way you feed something in a locked room, because keeping it alive is the point.

The lock screen showed a photograph he had taken himself: Lily at three, on this deck, in a red swimsuit, laughing with her whole face, reaching for the camera — for him — with both hands. Elena had set it as her wallpaper the day he sent it to her and had never changed it. The little girl in the photograph was six now and sitting ten feet away in a yellow dress, and the woman who owned the phone had not seen her grow.

He pressed his thumb to the home button. The phone asked for a code, four digits, patient as a locked door.

He did not have to think. Elena had set her codes carelessly and sentimentally and exactly once, and never changed them: it was the door code of the first flat they had rented together in Chicago, the number he had punched a thousand times with his arms full of groceries. 1-9-2-4. His thumb moved almost before he gave it leave.

The phone opened like a room he had lived in.

For a moment there was too much to take in, and his eyes went, stupidly, to the ordinary: her apps in their old arrangement, the weather still set to a Chicago suburb they had left years ago. Then the messages rose to meet him.

His own name stood at the top of the list, pinned there. CALEB. And beneath it, the beginning of the last message in the thread, in his own words: *Lily lost a tooth today. She put it under—*

News in the same category

The Little Girl in the Yellow Dress Who Pointed at the Pool and Said Her Mother Was Under the Water

45 Part